Re:How Bad Is the Coronavirus? Let’s Run the Numbers
by fanf2 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:02PM
(#22579060)
There are some good charts at http://nrg.cs.ucl.ac.uk/mjh/covid19/ which show a change in growth rate in Italy near the start of March, possibly due to the lockdown in Lombardy a week earlier
Re:How Bad Is the Coronavirus? Let’s Run the Numbers
by maxerickson on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:46PM
(#22578971)
A possible explanation is that their testing can't keep up with the spread. ~13,000 test per day for the last several days, with more positive results yesterday for the same number of tests.
Re:How Bad Is the Coronavirus? Let’s Run the Numbers
by throwaway_pdp09 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:56PM
(#22579029)
If true that would apply much more to the US data, where I understand the amount of testing has been extremely low.
In any case the data is surely of confirmed cases, so these have got past the testing, no? And I'm not sure if that would produce a flatter-than-exponential curve, which seems to be what it is.
Re:How Bad Is the Coronavirus? Let’s Run the Numbers
by maxerickson on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:09PM
(#22579478)
It depends on how many tests are needed. If they are running 13,000 and need 50,000, the growth will look flat.
And then for the US, if most places are doing a high percentage of the needed tests, then the test results should reflect the real growth. Given the limitations on testing, we likely won't have a good understanding of this for weeks to come (people on the internet saying they should have been tested is only worth so much).
I dumped this into Tableau, graphed it and put an exponential trend line over the top. The UK and US data dropped almost perfectly onto an exponential (R-squared > 0.99 for both, P value better than 0.0001 for both, whatever those mean). The visual fit was remarkably good.
The italian data very obviously did not fit so well. It clearly was flatter than the best fit exponential (strange, given that covid is totally ablaze there) and it had an R-squared of 0.946, though it's P value was still less than 0.0001.
Can anyone comment? The raw data for italy is below.
Edit: for comparison, US data is below.