I'm not criticizing you or your product, but if reliability is critical, it's made explicit with a realistic SLA.
We don't pretend, promise or have an SLA that offers 100% uptime.
I couldn't say what the average uptime is, but if a school network goes down we normally get an immediate call asking us if there is a problem our end because they use our system so heavily. So at a guess .. at least 98-99% for the majority of secondary schools, but don't quote me!
Also teachers/students/parents access the system from home so we have to keep it running 24/7.
Computers have become mission critical in schools now - lessons, paperwork, planning, organisation, telephones, intercoms, security cameras†, locks‡ were all computer-dependent. To date that school network is the most advanced, highest-uptime network I've ever worked on: two server rooms (network continues at almost full capacity with the loss of either) in separate locations and a backup server in a third location. Unplanned outages were basically non-existent, and the loss of any service was very rare and involved lots of people shouting at us :(
† Internal only, external were still on tape
‡ I don't mean all the doors open if the network goes down, but the electronic locks were controlled over the network
Yeah, 100% uptime is a crazy notion; but something always to be strived for nonetheless.
An SLA only ever guarantees commercial remedies, not service availability.
Apart from one of the latest colo providers we use I've witnessed downtime with every single one that offered ip transit with a 100% SLA. That's why we use at a minimum 3 geographically distant providers. So far this approach has not let us down.
Reminds me of the "unlimited mobile phone internet" plans here in the UK which in the fine print resolve to "fair use policy of 1GB a month) .. why can't companies just call a spade a spade.
Slightly off-topic, but in case there's genuine curiosity there: AIUI, most of the advertising standards rulings about "fair use" policies related to Internet and particularly mobile bandwidth were made quite some time ago, when expectations were very different. It is possible that this was not entirely coincidental, and was motivated by the legal teams at major service providers who saw the current situation coming.
Can the teacher still teach if the systems go down? Yes.
I've had first hand experience dealing with dozens of LA (what you call districts) technical teams that take this kind of attitude and frankly I find it appalling.
I remember when schools where trying to bring in electronic registration, and the LA network teams just didn't give a damn about the schools needs. Instead they made there own conclusions as to what the school needed, and to them, having a reliable network so the school could move into the 21st century wasn't one of them.
Schools are becoming more and more engaged in technology, and downtime and poorly maintained systems set teachers and the work they do, back. Teachers need to be able to rely on the technology, simple as that, no excuses.
You're not expected to reach 100%, but to admit defeat and argue for that defeat is poor form.
We have had 3 incidents in the last 7+ years. The first 2 occurred when we only had servers in one site.
1, http://www.risktec.co.uk/news/business-continuity-%E2%80%93-... (lasted days!!) 2, A thunderstorm knocked out the power to our datacenter, the backup UPS and generators both failed to engage. (lasted a day, we also took our business elsewhere)
After the 2nd outage we decided to take up additional colo space elsewhere in the country. This has worked for years and any failures in our life datacenter have quickly been switched over to a hot backup datacenter.
We have had around a half dozen minor interruptions caused by server component failures ( psu / hard drive). This is because it takes a few minutes to detect the failure and switch over to a backup.
3, The last major failure was with our DNS hosting. They decided to scratch our main zone from there records because of a billing error. Luckily for us it happened on the Friday before a weeks school holiday. Needless to say we took our business elsewhere.
I'm sure we have had other instances of downtime I can't remember, but that's pretty much us in a nutshell. No idea what our uptime on paper would be, funnily.
I would also bet your uptime is worse than you think if you're not actively measuring it. However, I'm sure it is "good enough". I doubt it is worth spending an order of magnitude more money to get better than 3 9's for your business, which is more or less the point of the article imo.
I find the percent availability -> hours of downtime chart on wikipedia to be a really helpful reference for these types of discussions: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_availability
I develop a web application that is used by schools and just can't entertain the notion of anything other than 100% uptime. I take the reliability of my product very very seriously. If one of my customers had a fire at their school and couldn't access our system for registers - that would be us and them up the proverbial creak without a paddle.
I've built up a company (over 7 years now) with a very good reputation for reliability and uptime. Don't assume that just because something is web based it doesn't require 100% uptime.