Re:Low-cost portable ventilator (2010)
by npunt on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:26AM
(#22574149)
We need to start making these immediately. Every day counts right now. Where’s the army of amateur hardware hackers and 3d printer folks that can start cranking away on this?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I was considering an ask HN on just this. Having an effort from makers and professionals to come up with designs for mechanical ventilators when things get dire.
Now I understand jerry rigging medical devices is not advisable. But a pandemic like this may get to the point where DIY solutions may offer the solution.
I heard from a general practitioner that mechanical ventilators also have fine pressure control. Which would make the whole system a lot more complex. So given that I figured the concept was to flawed. But the design by MIT doesn't have these fancy ventilator function either. So it seems a cheap, available, basic ventilator would still be valuable.
I think even in the US, there's a ton of defense contractors, which could produce a dozen of these in <2 weeks, iff they got told so. I don't think it's a 3d-printer problem though ;).
Speaking from experience, large US defense contractors are incapable of producing a single sheet of paper with the proper signoffs to make a plan to schedule a meeting about the need for ventilators in under two weeks.
Re:Low-cost portable ventilator (2010)
by radicalbyte on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:58AM
(#22574428)
There are enough normal contractors in the US that, if the will was there, you could be making hundreds of thousands of these in a month.