I've solicited feedback for RunFatBoy.net directly from Amazon. I always ask them specifically what they don't like about the site. I also make a statement along the lines of
"It's OK to be negative; I am looking to improve my site and any criticism is welcome. You actually have a chance at a bonus if your criticism helps to improve my site."
Sadly, some people need permission or an incentive before they feel comfortable giving an honest answer.
Re:My 1st experiment with Feedback Army
by henryprecheur on Thursday February 24, 2011 @01:00AM
(#2257089)
Yes, the answers' quality seemed very variable: the most critical answers were the most useful. I'd also be willing to pay a premium to get reviews from the "meanest" soldiers ;-)
Re:My 1st experiment with Feedback Army
by jasongullickson on Thursday February 24, 2011 @01:20AM
(#2257144)
"Feedback Drill Sergeant" perhaps?
Re:My 1st experiment with Feedback Army
by huhtenberg on Thursday February 24, 2011 @02:14AM
(#2257238)
My sentiments exactly.
I understand there is some give and take with how I ask my questions and analyze the results (ie: what you put in is what you get out to a certain extent) but it would be awesome to be able to pay more and limit your users to specific countries or regions (if this means moving off Amazon Turk so be it. I would pay much more money than you are currently charging for a higher quality service).