But soft numbers are a common issue with many areas of public health. In particular, analysis of the current pandemic suffers from both a "numerator" and "denominator" problem (http://conflict.lshtm.ac.uk/page_83.htm)
I think many of us are accustomed to getting high-quality stats when studying a process. But that's often not possible with a fast-moving public health issue.
I think you have to acknowledge the limitations of the data, but it can still be helpful.
The thing I _don't_ like about the JHU dashboard is that it doesn't really let you slice the data in interesting ways. For example, I'd like to be able to click on a country or state/province and see temporal data. This doesn't seem like it would be that difficult, but maybe I'm naive.
It would help forming an idea on how the current situation (in addition to the new cases) is going.
People who model the effects of climate change, like Nate Silver and the 538 crew, run thousands of simulations and present a summary. Even then you can get hung up on the "unknown unknowns".
For instance 1970s estimates of nuclear reactor accidents assumed the main risk was that the pressure vessel was going to burst. That's an easy risk to control, so you hardly ever hear of a pressure vessel bursting at a chemical plant, but all the time people blow up or suck in storage tanks that can't handle 1 psi of under or overpressure.
Now really a legacy nuclear power plant melts down 100% of the time if the power goes out and they can't start the emergency generators. That happens a lot more than bursting pressure vessels!
My point is: we have the tooling necessary to talk about this problem better, more accurately, more precisely, in real-time, and to cover more angles simultaneously - which would lead to better decisions. But we're not using it. At least not publicly.
(This is a part of a general issue of mine, that we absolutely suck at having any kind of data-based discussion; best what we do is exchange badly made charts and context-free data points. We should be exchanging and discussing whole dynamic models. But I suppose this wider issue can wait until we're done with the coronavirus mess.)
Of course, if the center of the prediction is horrifying, "people don't understand confidence intervals" then becomes a case of avoiding societal breakdown.
Why wo don't have anything from these bodies is a different story, so.
Assuming they have[0], my core issue is: why won't they share them? Society is not 100% made of illiterate rubes who can only add (but not multiply) and read a line chart (and get confused by a log scale). There's enough people who could make use of more sophisticated information, including politicians and political advisors.
The discussion about e.g. whether a country should stop mass gatherings now or later would be infinitely better if it wasn't just "I think so" and "we have to flatten the curve!!11", but instead if one could say "look, the WHO model shows it won't help much", or "an alternative model proposed by virologist X suggests that it has most benefits if done today; here, look at this chart", especially if people could play with the models themselves and propose corrections.
--
[0] - I'm not convinced; I have the feeling most work in this space is still done with Excel or basic Python and R toolkits.
also, I don't care about the tools they use. As lonfg as the results are correct.
> There's enough people who could make use of more sophisticated information, including politicians and political advisors.
Far be it from me to suggest politicians and political advisors are "illiterate rubes", however I can tell you with confidence that in my experience politicians don't like numbers and models and won't listen to you if you try to tell them about them. Fundamentally this means that even when they're not actually illiterate, they are functionally illiterate (unless of course said model serves their political interest exactly).
The problem with Star Trek (esp. TNG) is that it doesn't reflect reality at all. It gives you the idea that the people in charge really know what they're doing and are competent. In our reality, this simply isn't the case.
I love watching TNG reruns to relax. It lets me fantasize about living in a well-run society run by mostly competent people. That's not the society I live in now, but this is why this form of entertainment is called "escapist".
I know of a certain company whose entire purpose is building and selling a product that lets you plug in equations of complex, dynamic systems and play with the models to understand and predict things. Like serious, industrial-grade stuff that's used to design chemical plants. They could easily get a virologist on call and model the spread more sensibly, or even individual countries in detail, and release that - which would give a basis for people to discuss what to do and when in a much better way that's happening now. They'd probably also save themselves a year's worth of marketing expenses. But I don't see them, or any of their competitors doing anything like this.
I'm thoroughly disappointed. Is the ArcGIS dashboard from John Hopkins University really the best our civilization has to offer in terms of informing people and evidence-based discussions? Because while I want to believe that our politicians have more sophisticated tools available, I'm pretty sure they're just looking at the same dashboards and same news stories as we do.