No, they really didn't. Homes were tiny compared to modern American homes. Walls were often thin. Windows were often simply openings in the wall with no glass.
That's exactly part of my point. And it's well documented, though it may not seem obvious to modern Americans who tend to project images of modern homes onto the past.
I'm going to repeat myself here: I'm not advocating for more surveillance. That isn't at all why I commented on this.
I commented because I think you don't solve a problem by spouting deluded nonsense and pretending the world works differently than it does.
The fact that humans have a long history of living with all the neighbors knowing their business may be part of why surveillance is a thing. Some part of our monkey brains may be going "We really need to know everything about everybody and this makes sense." Understanding that may help people articulate better mental models concerning "What's wrong with this picture and what do we need to do differently?"
I realize people tend to not actually listen to what gets said and they project their baggage and fears onto the words of other people, but I absolutely am not not not not not advocating for more surveillance. I find social stuff fascinating and my experience suggests that understanding the social and psychological context is step one in trying to put a stop to bad patterns and finding better answers.
(Five nots in a row is maybe not the best way to emphasize my point, but we aren't supposed to type in all caps and I don't know what a good solution is.)
But back to the topic I still think surveillance being the historical norm isn't too accurate. For over a decade we got more and more surveillance with the justification of terrorism, civil unrest and security. Similar aspirations are probably numerous throughout history.
I think everyone favors stability at some point, but to me it looks like the classical ambition to remain in control and fears that cannot really explained by a rational risk analysis, even if officials are in a position of responsibility. But I don't think that many people are keen on monitoring others. There is gossip, but that mostly happens due to nearly the same motivation or is just a detached way to reaffirm each other.
It would be pretty easy to get supporters against censorship. Instead these security measures are creating the dissidents it fears so much.
Probably a language thing, the fault of English. ("FTFY")
I'm recovering from a mold exposure, something I'm allergic to. When I'm not coughing up phlegm, I'm conked out and sleeping hard. So I'm done with this discussion, having nothing whatsoever to do with anything anyone here said.
In the U.S., anonymity is a "fundamental right" only in certain circumstances and it differs by state. It's not a blanket right.
>Even in small towns and villages people had privacy inside their houses, farms etc.
This is still a thing if you choose it.
That's debatable, someone can legally "park" a drone above your back yard or in front of a window and the only legal thing you can do is to shield your life behind a non-transparent medium (board your windows).
Someone can legally access your private data coming from ISPs, mobile operators, any number of devices in your house, etc. and the only legal thing you can do is cut yourself off from all of those services that admittedly are more or less a requirement for modern life.
The examples can continue. Saying "if you choose it" doesn't do it justice, the choice comes with severe and likely unreasonable sacrifices relative to what society offers and expects/demands these days.
The fact that you have to choose between not using internet or mobile phone (both relatively critical in this day and age), or implicitly give a private company the right to use your (meta)data in any way they see fit is basically an admission that privacy is not enforced, it's taken away from you. In the past nobody logged all of your physical visits around the city, and certainly not at any substantial scale, so the topic never made sense even if you were crossing public space. You can't judge the present by the laws made for the past. You don't just have the right to bear a musket because that's what existed when the Constitution was written. So privacy should refer to the principle, not the actual mechanism and implementation.
Drone related, things are more nuanced. The drone may be in my back yard but filming in yours no matter how tall your fence. And unlike a real person hovering around your house, a drone operator is anonymous for all intents and purposes. Unlike a real person, a drone or (hidden) cameras throughout a city can be out of sight but "remembering" everything. You don't have to get away with it for long. The fact that you can get away with it once is enough of an open door. Once here, once there, and pretty soon your phone collecting every piece of private information about you and sending it out is perfectly acceptable.
Not in my country and I would imagine that you may be allowed to shoot that tin can down in the US.
But legislation is both easy and effective. There is a huge difference for privacy if compromising information is legally obtained or not. Sure, some will ignore it that can be addressed separately. Again, legislation would be extremely easy.
ISPs can use your data because it isn't legislated otherwise. But even there are limits and not all information can be legally accessed. A solution would be to use the network of your neighbor, but I am sure we wouldn't want to escalate this problem further.
This is the debatable part. The FAA considers drones to be aircraft—and under federal law, shooting at aircraft is a crime [0]. The devil's in the details of course. Such cases were usually dismissed because it means trying whether a drone is considered to be trespassing or not and no judge wants to touch this.
The best precedent on this is from the 1946 States v. Causby when the Supreme Court ruled that a farmer in North Carolina could assert property rights up to 83 feet in the air. [1]
Again, the law failed to keep up with the ever accelerating evolution of tech and the SC will probably have to weigh in on pretty much every topic soon, to tweak the interpretation of every outdated law.
> information is legally obtained
Which is why I said that it's not a real choice, not if you have to give up things that are considered more or less basic needs or requirements today. That's because most such information is obtained perfectly legally so there is no recourse. Internet tracking, real life face recognition at every step, all your devices collecting data on you, your "choice" is to pretty isolate yourself from society. Is it a realistic choice then?
[0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/32
[1] http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-supreme-court/328/256.html
It's not a "long-standing norm", it's a fundamental right, as most, if not all, fundamental rights we have today.
> When everyone you know lives in a really small area
Even in small towns and villages people had privacy inside their houses, farms etc.
But from now on, it's constant surveillance everywhere, all the time.