News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking by goto11 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @08:07AM (#22545056)
The issue is when nobody really knows...the fence have just been there as long as anybody remember. Then people start to make up justification. Maybe the fence protect against trolls? Maybe the fence is important for the moral character of the population, and if it is removed people will think there are no limits to anything and will soon descend into murder and cannibalism. Better safe than sorry!
Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking by api on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @11:55AM (#22546820)
The issue is also when the fence was there for horrible reasons, e.g. "that fence is there to keep the underclass in their ghetto."

Of course I suppose it still works in that case. You found the reason. The reason sucked. Therefore, remove it.

Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking by winstonewert on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:06PM (#22550617)
Is that an objection against the story's point?

The fact that people might come up with silly/nonsensical/bad justifications for the fence doesn't seem undermine the importance of doing due diligence to determine if there is a good reason for the fence in the first place.

Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking by goto11 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @04:32AM (#22554841)
Due diligence is great, but it is an objection against the default stance of keeping the fence if you can't explain why it is there. The fence becomes onions in the varnish or cargo cult. At least in software development it is poison to have too many "we cant change that area of the code, nobody understand what it does". Sometimes you just have to tear down the fence and observe the consequences.
Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking by winstonewert on Thursday March 12, 2020 @10:01AM (#22556922)
I guess I don't read the parable as insisting that we have to keep the fence if we can't find the reason for it after due diligence. It simply doesn't try to speak to that case.
Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking by goto11 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:21AM (#22557760)
It is stated quite explicitly in the article: "Do not remove a fence until you know why it was put up in the first place."

It follows that you can't remove a fence if you cant figure out why it was created in the first place.

Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking by winstonewert on Thursday March 12, 2020 @01:04PM (#22558965)
What are you, some kind of robot? (If so, awesome!) This is natural language, you can't treat it like a statement in predicate logic.

Its very common in natural language to state general principles which apply most of the time without intending it to be an iron-clad rule that would apply in any circumstances without exception.

For example, if there is a "Stay off the grass" sign, you'd avoid going on the grass, but you'd still go on if the need was important enough.

The case of being unable to find the reason is an exceptional circumstance in which the principle does not apply, at least in quite the same way.