Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking
by xamuel on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:48PM
(#22542799)
Whoops. You just removed the fence which was put in place thousands of years ago to contain radioactive waste with a million-year half-life. You couldn't read the warning signs since they were written in an ancient long-forgotten script. So you assumed it must be unimportant.
Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking
by Firadeoclus on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @07:19AM
(#22544817)
Luckily, material with a million-year half-life would be barely radioactive.
And what's the alternative? To assume that every barrier in existence we can't explain is important and must therefore be maintained forever?
Re:Chesterton’s Fence: A Lesson in Second Order Thinking
by xamuel on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:25PM
(#22549472)
One alternative would be for you to follow the prescription, "find out why the fence was put there, then I may allow you to remove it". Investigate what's on the other side of the fence, without tearing it down (this might involve experimentally re-discovering the theory of radiation, depending on the current state of mankind's knowledge). Then go back to the authority and report that the fence seems to be there to contain radioactive waste with a million-year half-life. Armed with this information, the authority will be in a better position to determine whether or not to allow you to tear down the fence.
Or does he perhaps suspect that they haven't thought about it enough? After all, they can't have truly understood why hierarchies were first instituted, because they have failed to see the benefits he so obviously believes hierarchical organization has.
See, this is the problem with Chesterton's fence. You tell the reformer to go away and think about why the fence is there, and then she comes back and tells you the fence was put there to keep her out. And you say 'ah, poor child, you still don't really understand why the fence is there.'
Sometimes the burden of proof needs to be the other way round.
We're ripping out that fence. And if someone wants to keep it, they need to go away and think and, if they can tell us why that fence needs to continue to exist, only then can they stop us.