News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To do better science, admit that you’re not objective by generationP on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @05:54PM (#22540175)
I think good points can be made in favor of not ignoring the context when (a) the science cannot be evaluated independently (so you have to take it on trust or ditch it), or (b) there are reasons to suspect publication bias (i.e., results are reported/published more if they fit certain biases). So yes for many parts of biology and psychology, but no for maths or much of the hard sciences (at least not the older stuff that has been repro'd many times).

Speaking of "isolation from the past", the linked opinion piece doesn't cite a single reference other than the author's own pop-sci book. An interesting decision for sure.

Re:To do better science, admit that you’re not objective by a1369209993 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:10PM (#22540964)
If it can't be evaluated independently it's not science. At all. The defining feature of science, as opposed to superstition and recieved "wisdom" is that you don't have to take it on trust. (If it's merely difficult to evaluate independently, it might be legit, but you should still be suspicious of it.) Publication bias is admittedly more a problem.
Re:To do better science, admit that you’re not objective by generationP on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:31PM (#22541153)
Yeah, I should have said "infeasible to evaluate".