NeXT did have a working M88K[1] system, that booted and ran. The case was a slightly taller version of the NeXTStation. Then they killed all hardware.
However the pa-risc systems were the best you could run NS/OS on. Intel might be faster but it was a pain to setup. 712/100 just ran and ran smoothly.
[1] http://www.nextcomputers.org/forums/index.php?topic=1271.msg...
http://www.nextcomputers.org/NeXTfiles/Images/Rare_NeXT_Hard...
EDIT: Changed powerpc to m88K.
Intel and Microsoft were busy eating the world, and one of the things that got gobbled up was the market segment NeXT was hoping to sell into.
I found it very ironic that the biggest market for PDP-11-compatible micros was one not actually open to DEC: the Soviet Union.
I knew a guy who earned a living rehabbing PDPs that had done service in McDonald's. I guess they weren't always located in the best place in the building because said he spent most of his time cleaning the dried soda off of circuit boards.
There are also rumours that around 1980, there was a design at Digital that could have led to a PDP-10 workstation, but Digital wanted to kill PDP-10.
When I asked about it, the answer was simple: Three Dells were cheaper than one Sun.
There were a bunch of dropped balls there. To rattle off a few:
* They targeted academic institutions first, which very much constrained their market, and didn't align well with the $6,500 base price. Which turned into closer to $10K once you bought a disk and printer. (Slightly more than $20K in 2020 dollars.)
* Disk performance on a base Cube was terrible, thanks to the reliance on an Magento-Optical disk as primary storage. (Seek times x3-4 of magnetic disks.)
* Their hardware was very good, but it's expensive to be in the hardware business and others had the resources to vastly outcompete them.
* Choice of 68K didn't help. NeXT got two chips (030 and 040) before they started having to look elsewhere. (There was an 060 that even got used in some accelerator boards, but the market was in a wholesale shift over to RISC by that time. It also can't have helped that Motorola's own RISC follow on to the 68K, the 88K, got almost immediately replaced by their PPC venture with IBM and Apple.)
If I had to sum up the NeXT, I'd call it "a much better Mac". Which isn't surprising given that Jobs started right after getting forced out of Apple, and took a number of Mac folks with him. But as you say, $6,500 was way too much for the Mac's strongest market, education; that's like $13k in 2020 dollars.
Instead it was priced like a workstation, but it also wasn't great for that, in that it was a totally new OS and didn't have much software available out of the gate. I've heard of multiple schools that ended up with NeXT labs where almost nobody used them.
The only niche where I really saw adoption was with financial traders, who had money to burn and liked the rapid development speed you could get compared with other platforms of the day. But that was never a goal, just a happy accident.
So in retrospect, I feel the whole thing was not about helping any specific customer, but about Steve Jobs and his feelings about getting booted from Apple.
My university was one of these. We had a huge lab filled with shiny NeXT cubes... which, for reasons unknown, was owned by the communications department.
Just try to imagine the befuddlement of a bunch of early ‘90s journalism majors who have just been seated in front of Unix workstations. No matter what you imagine, I guarantee the reality was worse.
Which is pretty much how it wound up, eventually.
[1] https://books.google.com/books?id=OzoEAAAAMBAJ see page 44
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NeXT_RISC_Workstation?wprov=sf...
I’m sure some of them would have happened anyway in some other form, but that’s still pretty amazing.
But yep the contemporary RISCs were faster than the 68k's nevermind those microarchitectural features.
My employers were signed up as NeXT and Sun developers and for what we were doing, the former was such a disappointment even if was pleasant to use (other than as an NFS server but that's another story...).
While SPARC was proprietary (and PA and POWER were still in the future) MIPS was actually shipping chips at the time for general sale. Why NeXT didn't go with them I don't know.