What is it that you want out of these sites? Expert Opinion? Helpful articles? The Zeitgeist among your peers? The analysis of the community might help you decide how to use a site to your liking, but because it is superficial, it will be of little help. Seek out the experts yourself or trim through the article listings yourself instead of basing it completely on a democratic vote system. The quality of the community will only make this process more convenient, but it is the quality of individual posters that define what is most helpful to you.
Now, I would like to compile a list of posters whom I can trust for insightful comments on a particular matter instead of posting assumptions.
So far, I know of pg, joshu...crap, I wish there were avatars here. Why was I stuck with just visual memory like a common human? Unicode avatars would have been helpful: ❤
Even if HN has lost its edge over time that fundamental difference is worth fighting for and worth coming back to HN.
EDIT: Never mind, I just unsubscribed from all the default reddits and it's still mostly crap. Carry on...