News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by democracy on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @06:50PM (#2252171)
Why not just do the time-sheets?
Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by mgkimsal on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @11:01PM (#2252969)
I've been at a few companies that required timesheets of software devs, and it was always weird/awkward at best. They never wanted just hours - they wanted to know what was done as well.

Sometimes it's easy, sometimes it's not, but the thing that bugged me was that it eventually was used against you.

Mgr: "Oh.. well.. I see here you've only put in 38 hours on core projects this last week... this doesn't look too good to others."

Me: "Well, I was actually here in the building for 46 hours, but 8 of those hours were doing some other stuff that there's no timesheet entries for."

Mgr: "Oh... like what?"

Me: "Like answering questions from people in the building that have questions about some of the projects I'm working on - status updates, etc. Apparently you and the other managers aren't updating anyone, and they ask me."

Mgr: "That's not your job."

Me: "So... I should silently ignore them, or give them a canned response to go ask their own dept manager?"

Mgr: "yes. But that didn't take 8 hours last week!"

Me: "I was also doing some research on a couple new debugging tools."

Mgr: "There's no need for that - the senior engineers are making their decision next week about what tool you'll use."

Me: "OK...."

Mgr: "I don't want to see you make a habit of 38 hours a week from now on."

Me: "Ummm... the last 3 months I've been putting in 45-50 hours non-stop, and have been in on some weekends to work with some other people to hit the deadlines."

Mgr: "Yeah, that's great, but 38 hours..."

This is a composite of discussions I've had and colleagues have had with various managers over the years whenever timesheets are involved. YMMV.

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by danssig on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @09:03AM (#2254077)
You're taking all this a bit too seriously. It is not time efficient to log what you actually do, so what I always do is just ask my manager what percentage of my time is supposed to go where. Once I know I just fill my time sheet out that way. The whole thing is effectively just a double booking of project spending anyway. It baffles me why everyone does this manually instead of automating it. I don't really need to be involved at all.

EDIT: Thought better of it and changed my message. But I still think your manager is a moron since he's unable to point out the above, and life is too short to work for people like that.

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by mgkimsal on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @09:24AM (#2254137)
Just for the record - this is a composite of various conversations over the years, and does not reflect specifically on any one manager I've directly reported to.

Also... I'm taking it too seriously? Over a 2 month period when, say, 400 hours are logged, but one week 2 hours are not accounted for in a specified (yet unspoken, hint hint, nudge, nudge) manner, and I'm taking it too seriously?

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by danssig on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @11:19AM (#2254587)
Ok, so seriously isn't the correct word. You're taking it too literally. They don't want to know how many seconds you spent typing code or thinking about code. They have a budget where some department has purchased 40 hours per week for you to work on their main project. Presumably you have smaller time bookings for other tasks. If you break this down it will come out to something like:

98% main

1% support

0.5% boss' pet task

0.5% other

All they want is for your time sheet to match that because that's what they've paid for. Some managers are smart enough to just tell you that, others (like the one you appear to have) don't like to say it for some reason. They should just automate it because the numbers you plug in are completely static.

It's just double booking, one side put in a "debit" for the project and now you're putting in the "credit" side saying it was paid. No one cares what you actually did because the exact moments you spent on the project shouldn't affect anything (assuming you're not a problem worker).

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by mgkimsal on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @03:00PM (#2255541)
And if you have 50+ hours on a project for several weeks, but only 38 on another week, who's taking things too literally? I still don't see it. Look for habitual slackers, look for trends, but don't hit someone who's coming off a sustained period of 'over and above' work effort with the insinuation that they're somehow slacking. Had it happen to me directly once, and seen it happen with other people.

The places I've been without timesheets have generally been less stressful overall, and I think the 'fit things in to a timesheet' model contributed to that stress (for me and for others).

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by danssig on Thursday February 24, 2011 @02:59AM (#2257303)
I still don't think you're seeing what I'm saying.

I used to get stressed about time sheets, same as you. Then I had a manager who told me what they were really for. Since then I always put in the stock work week, broken down how ever it is supposed to be broken down. Regardless of what I actually work. I keep my real hours in a personal spread sheet so I know how much time I'm over or under and actually work from that.

As a side note, this extra time you're working is just time thrown in the trash. No one is going to thank you for it and if everyone else is doing the same thing you wont even get any kind of promotion for it since it's not "above and beyond". I know, I used to work 60+ hours for a company. Up until the day they laid me off.

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by dennisgorelik on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @03:08AM (#2253474)
Mgr could not say it directly, but he implied that timesheet must have 40 hours reported on the main project. How hard could that be to write it down like that?

I understand that it's still unpleasant to deal with that.

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by mgkimsal on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @07:21AM (#2253837)
So... lie. If they want dishonesty, just ask for it.
Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by bad_user on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @08:37AM (#2254008)
I used to do it. Incredibly easy too.

Like once, in a sprint that took 5 weeks, the last week was scheduled for bug-fixes / quality assurance. I did nothing for 3 and a half weeks, finished my assignments in 2 days, then for a whole week I just fixed a couple superficial bugs here and there.

Reported time: ~ 170 hours.

EDIT: to expand on this point, the secret is in how you do the initial estimation. Hugely overestimate the small / easy tasks (explain with technical babble if needed) , then underestimate the difficult tasks. So not only will you secure lots of free time, but you'll also be that genius that finishes difficult tasks in 1 hour :-)

Heck, you might even be promoted to management; that's how all the cool kids in management are doing it :)

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by dennisgorelik on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @08:09AM (#2253931)
The manager wanted to see 40 hours reported against his main project.

He did not want dishonesty, but probably would not mind some tweaking in how work activities are categorised in a timesheet.

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by rbarooah on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @11:40AM (#2254695)
How is this 'not wanting dishonesty'?
Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by tptacek on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @07:24PM (#2252295)
For one thing, because it is part of the way that your team is turned into a Resource. I never watched Star Trek, but I'm pop-culture literate, and my understanding is they use something called "nanoprobes" to effect the process of "assimilation".

Once you're assimilated, business decisions that impact your team become an MBA math abstraction to the parent company leadership. Time sheets are BigCo's mechanism for mapping what people to do top-down business objectives. The tops of most BigCo's think they have a strategy, but usually don't.

Also, there is something about timecard software that brings out the worst in enterprise software developers. I have never, ever seen one implemented well. I get to see a lot of them in this job.

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by wh-uws on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @11:56PM (#2253109)
there is something about timecard software that brings out the worst in enterprise software developers. I have never, ever seen one implemented well.

If I could upvote that a thousand times I would.

Why o why is this so true? And why hasn't anyone done anything about it?

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by zeemonkee on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @02:50AM (#2253446)
Having recently been forced to use one maybe I have a little bit of perspective.

The problem I believe, is, fundamentally, the need for managers to justify their existence. Whereas other roles in the organization - engineers, salespeople, secretaries - have clear reason for their existence and work they can point to (code written, products sold, paychecks processed) managers do not.

The fact that nobody reads any of these timesheets and that project estimates based on hours are a complete nonsensical fiction are really beside the point. The point is that the very production of this work is taken as proof that the manager, too, is producing valuable work.

In small startups timesheets are irrelevant because everyone has their heads down getting on with the job. Managers exist, but the company can't afford to have people who just "manage". They do other valuable roles - whether technical or sales or office admin. The sign of a company "growing up" is when you suddenly have all these new people you have to report to, with ill-defined titles like "Product Delivery Manager" - and the timesheets.

OK, but why are timesheet programs so badly designed ? The hardest thing in software development is to design something that's ill-defined - in other words, if the purpose of the program is a bad one, it's really hard to build a good program to fulfill that purpose. Simple timekeeping software isn't hard but management have so many nonsensical requirements that the software increases in complexity and correspondingly decreases in usability.

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by petervandijck on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @07:31AM (#2253854)
To timesheet software makers: you pretty much must have an "other" option in many of your dropdowns. That will solve a lot of problems right there. Here's why:

http://poorbuthappy.com/ease/archives/2010/11/23/4827/data-c...

and

http://poorbuthappy.com/ease/archives/2010/11/27/4832/why-ge...

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by yuhong on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @01:10AM (#2253280)
Yea I know, the myth that a MBA can manage everything.
Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by InclinedPlane on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @08:04PM (#2252458)
Because creating software is a creative endeavor that requires talented and skilled individuals working imaginatively. Timesheets and other bureaucratic overhead are poisonous to that process.

The best software can't be created in a factory assembly line with interchangeable drones.

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by democracy on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @08:27PM (#2252523)
So the companies acquired by Yahoo created the best software? Even from the technical point of view the majority is an average project and an average team, I really don't see why someone acquired is different from the rest of the owner company.
Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by InclinedPlane on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @09:24PM (#2252716)
In some cases, yes (flickr, delicious, etc.)

If you're implying that Yahoo's MO is to acquire companies and convert them into pumping out hum-drum, mediocre software, well, that sounds about right.

Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by ajays on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @11:56PM (#2253108)
I don't know why you're dragging Yahoo into the timesheets discussion. Yahoo does not have timesheets.
Re:What happens after Yahoo acquires you by petervandijck on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @07:03PM (#2252213)
You have to draw the line somewhere. Early and clearly is best.