So I think the trust model bears scoping. It's not all or nothing.
As it happens, Debian itself kinda does this (Debian "maintainers" can only upload to specific package names), but I don't think anyone else runs that software. The usual third-party repo tools like reprepro and aptly don't support it, as far as I know. And sites like Launchpad or OBS just set up a separate apt repo per account (or even multiple apt repos per account), because doing that is very easy.
In other words - yes, the trust model you propose is coherent, but I don't think anyone actually does that, because there's a more straightforward option already.
But this is hard to do correctly for deb repositories. We first need to come up with a way to declare repository groups so you can say that e.g. the security repo can provide updates to the main repo.