Re:The EARN IT act is an attack on end-to-end encryption
by throwaway17_17 on Friday March 06, 2020 @11:06PM
(#22509667)
Just to put some rough numbers on it:
- 393,000,000 firearms owned by US citizens
- 39,773 firearm related deaths (including suicide) as a decent base yearly rate [this is the actual 2017 number]
14,542 firearm homicides as a decent base yearly rate [again, actual 2017 number]
If you’re going to insist on a teleological argument, you might as well use the same standard we use for other tools: how people actually end up using them. No rational person describes knives as “tools to stab people” even though this is part of the historical basis for their development. Instead, the vast majority of knives are used to cut food or spread butter or open boxes. Indeed, these are all more plausible descriptions of what a knife is “for”, just like target shooting or hunting food is a much more plausible description of what guns are for.