Re:Ask HN: What industries are underserved by software?
by spaceandshit on Monday March 09, 2020 @11:20AM
(#22526075)
Are you familiar with DO-178? Basically outputs have to be deterministic.. so you can't really use advanced control techniques.
I haven't worked on flight control (but control on specific aircraft systems, which are at the same level), and they're all basically PID control thrown together.
Re:Ask HN: What industries are underserved by software?
by wenc on Monday March 09, 2020 @03:27PM
(#22528805)
Ah no, aircraft control is outside of my province, so this is new knowledge.
Advanced control can be deterministic -- through parameterization. Explicit MPC [1] does this. It pre-computes the quadratic optimization problem offline, so all the solutions are enumerated and stored, and are verifiable. However, as far as I know no one has implemented this commercially.
Interesting that it's all PID. Not surprised though because PID is tried-and-true (but even so, has a lot of tiny nuances which takes years to understand).
[1] https://www.mathworks.com/help/mpc/explicit-mpc-design.html
Re:Ask HN: What industries are underserved by software?
by spaceandshit on Monday March 09, 2020 @11:46PM
(#22532565)
Thanks for the link, I was not familiar. I'm not sure if any current commercial systems use these methods.
I know the defense industry uses a lot of advanced techniques because they're their own regulators.
What control scheme do aircraft use today? I always thought it was a form of MPC (well GPC = generalized predictive control) with a state estimator like a linear Kalman filter.