News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Physicists Discover Quantum Law Of Protein Folding by gus_massa on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @09:57AM (#2250015)
There are some extrange detals in the original paper.

For example the experimental points in the graphics do not have error bars. The x axis is 1/temperature, so the error should be small. But in the y axis I spect that the measures have a more visible error. Some of the graphics ("Protein A", "L9") have a very good theoretical fitting, so it is possible that the experimental data have very small errors. But in others graphics ("Engrailed Homeo Domain", "Trpcage(WT)") the points are scattered around the theoretical fitting, so perhaps the measures have a appreciable error or the theoretical fitting has problems.

And in the lasts graphics the fitting is not very good. In particular in "Villin Headpiece Subdomain" the fitting id horrble. I see that the experimental point lie in something like an "U" but the fit is like a shallow "^".

Another problem is that they have too many free parameters: "R" and "S" are free. And "Tc" is free too (it is an experimental value, not deduced from the model). But near the maximal point of the curve, everything is almost a parabola, so with 3 free parameters it is possible to fit almost everything. For example, for the first graphic ("Protein A") a possible fit using thee parameters is

  ln(K_1)= -7.4161 * (1000/T - 3.1469)^2 + 12.418
They have a more difficult functional dependency, but with tree free parameters it is not clear that they have the correct model.

There are no comments on this comment yet.