Re:Physicists Discover Quantum Law Of Protein Folding
by hagy on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @02:47PM
(#2251201)
Exactly! This high level model doesn’t draw on any quantum specific phenomena and is in many ways comparable to other stochastic dynamical models that have been developed to explain the non-Arrhenius behavior of protein folding using classical Langevin theory.
To argue for the inclusion of quantum theory in explaining protein dynamics is to assert that proteins undergo classically forbidden conformational transitions. The authors of the paper have provided no evidence for such transitions nor even hypothesized about how such transitions could arise. Their only argument against a classical description of protein folding is the inability of molecular dynamics simulations to model the folding-kinetics of some proteins. Seeing as molecular dynamics force fields only provide a rough and approximate description of the forces between atoms within a protein it should be no surprise these methods can’t accurately model the intricate conformational transitions in protein folding.
Re:Physicists Discover Quantum Law Of Protein Folding
by bioh42_2 on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @09:58AM
(#2250022)
I am not sure Newtonian dynamics would give you similar predictions, but that doesn't mean the quantum predictions are wrong. However, with enough free parameters you can model anything. When you have 0 free parameters you have a real theory.
Several things must occur before you can say it's real: does it apply to other molecules, what are the sources of the differences between prediction and measurement, do molecules while folding really undergo some sort of non-continuous motion and can it be detected and why hasn't it ever been seen before, and do the matching corresponding Newtonian+statistical dynamics give similar predictions?