News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by wtfrmyinitials on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:35AM (#22495074)
During a shortage:

Commodity is available. Commodity is affordable.

Pick 1.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by sp332 on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:42AM (#22495177)
"Available" for a price people can't pay is still a reduction in availability.
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by daxorid on Thursday March 05, 2020 @03:41PM (#22497948)
There's no kinder way to say this:

People who make fun of "doomsday preppers" and cast social opprobrium to those who chose to lengthen their own personal supply chain can go get fucked.

Zero sympathy to those who cry of shortages or price gouging, but thought it more prudent to buy NVDA at astronomically ridiculous earnings multiples than spend three dollars a week on a few extra household supplies at a time when said supplies were cheap.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by whatshisface on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:43AM (#22495187)
People have some flexibility, though, in the price they are willing to pay. So it is not as bad as an empty shelf.
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by orev on Thursday March 05, 2020 @12:32PM (#22495803)
To mitigate the price rise during a shortage, I have been thinking about an insurance-type structure. If a supply runs short, there’s a very real need for people to actually produce the product, but that can result in having to call more people in to work, longer hours, overtime, etc. And there’s also the extra cost of delivery.

With an insurance structure in place to provide funds during these situations, it would allow a quicker response without as much of a spike in prices. Companies could draw the funding for these increased costs from the insurance instead.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by ThJ on Friday March 06, 2020 @11:32AM (#22504874)
This is what futures contracts are for. They are settled with a physical delivery or in cash, depending on the contract.

Futures trading is a prediction market. If you produce a commodity, you could, for example, place a sell order that is settled on a certain date in the future, and if you’re lucky, the market price will be below that of the price set in the order.

The buyer of the future will then purchase the commodity from you at the agreed price, or for cash settled futures, he’ll pay you the difference.

If the market price is higher, the difference is paid to the buyer, if the future is cash settled.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by formercoder on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:38AM (#22495120)
3) government intervenes
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by jolmg on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:48AM (#22495267)
And does what? make more supply appear from thin air?
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by formercoder on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:50AM (#22495293)
Resource allocation that favors public wellbeing over market efficiency.
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by jolmg on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:59AM (#22495405)
Market efficiency is precisely about public wellbeing. Concretely, what are you suggesting? In face of limited supply, there's only 2 choices: keep the prices low or raise the prices. The former accelerates supply depletion; the latter helps maintain supply availability. You're asking for the government to come in and pull a third choice out of their sleeve, but I don't see such a choice. If you're the government, concretely, what would you do?

EDIT: Now, if you suspect price gouging, that's different. wtfrmyinitials was referring to a genuine shortage, though.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by formercoder on Thursday March 05, 2020 @12:23PM (#22495687)
That’s true if the proposed intervention is simply price caps, as opposed to rationing.
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by DuskStar on Thursday March 05, 2020 @04:44PM (#22498685)
And does what? Mandates that hand sanitizer not exceed some price/oz? There'll still be shortages, because some whales will buy it all. Mandate caps on the amount that a person can buy? I suppose hospitals are fucked then, and that's assuming that people don't circumvent the restrictions anyways.

So the only way to "solve" the issue is to add more supply, and "price through the roof" is as good a way to get more supply (and possibly better) as the government mandating more production.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by daxorid on Thursday March 05, 2020 @03:50PM (#22498061)
A bottle of isopropanol, prior to this event, cost approximately 79 cents.

The only change to resource allocation we need is a psychological one: specifically, to accept the idea that prepping, even at a very small level, is not insane.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by platz on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:52AM (#22495327)
You assume the price is at equilibrium.

If there is gouging, that's definitely not the case.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by belltaco on Thursday March 05, 2020 @12:39PM (#22495884)
If the price is being "gouged" by the manufacturer, doesn't that mean they will ramp up production much faster? The extra money will also help them hedge against the risk of overproduction if the thing fizzles out fast.

Not to mention people are less likely to unnecessarily hoard years worth of supplies and prevent others from using it if it's more expensive.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by eveningcoffee on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:54AM (#22495345)
I think it is called rationing.
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by wpietri on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:47AM (#22495244)
That's my preference. Markets are generally great, but in extreme conditions intervention is necessary. This happens in non-governmental markets, too. For example, I know stock exchanges and commodities markets have all sorts of mechanisms to prevent market failure.
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by wheelie_boy on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:43AM (#22495194)
That's just rationing, the same thing as 'commodity is affordable'.

Or maybe you're expecting it to not be a real shortage?

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by Proziam on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:54AM (#22495350)
4) People take preventative measures.

It's not that hard to have some extra cleaning supplies, non-perishable food, and water around. I don't understand the desire to have the government spend a multiple in tax dollars for what I could just keep in the house myself?

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by mrguyorama on Thursday March 05, 2020 @02:04PM (#22496857)
Plenty of people can't afford to buy toilet paper in bulk. What do you recommend for them?
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by Proziam on Thursday March 05, 2020 @02:41PM (#22497293)
If everyone who could afford to handle their own lives and responsibilities did, the role of government could actually be to prop up the bottom x% and keep things stable. If 90% of people make no preparations, there's no possible way to respond in a way that you can save everyone from a serious disaster.

Sadly, whether you think it's 70% or 90% that could get themselves organized and take responsibility for their own security makes little difference in the real world because almost nobody actually does. The world went from victory gardens to big brother and people seem to prefer it this way.

Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:42AM (#22495179)
Now the commodity is neither available nor affordable!
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by formercoder on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:49AM (#22495285)
I generally favor markets but one of the main reasons we have a federal government is to do everything required in this type of situation. Stay away as much as you can, but be there when we need you.
Re:$194 for hand sanitizer? You must be joking by omginternets on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:45AM (#22495225)
... but it can be more intelligently allocated.

Sometimes an ideal market is the worst possible thing.