"Already before the change, the graphic designer Peter Saville had described Google’s logo as infantile: ‘Everything about it is childlike: the colors [sic], the typeface, even the name’ (Rawsthorn 2010). The redesign had intensified this. Chris Moran, at that time The Guardian’s search engine editorial optimizer, described the new look and feel as a turn towards ‘My First Search Engine’ (Moran 2010). "
This is hardly a surprising characterization, too. Simple, shadowless shapes that emphasize colours is exactly what children draw.
She cites a single person, Chris Moran, from personal communcation. Chris Moran is not a designer, but an editor.
Peter Saville is quoted in an article from before they removed the drop shadow and deemphasized the shading in the logo. It is the author who suggests that reducing the 3-dimensional style of the logo "intensified" its childlike qualities, and not Peter Saville, who had not seen the redesign when he made his comment.
Edit: FWIW, it's not designs that are just flat that the author considers child-like. It's a design vocabulary that uses flat designs, cartoonish characters (e.g. Octocat), addressing users in a child-like manner that's seen as childish. Flatness is just one element of this vocabulary.
It is also what children like to look at. They dont appreciate elaborate realism or shadows. They prefer simple shape, uniform color and no shade.
Children draw basic forms and use basic colours because they don't yet understand how to interpret the world in a complex way. They abstract, and draw their abstraction - tables are square, therefore the image on the page needs to be square to be a table. Untrained adults do the same.
But mostly, it is not just about primary colors. It is more of preference for bright (primary does not matter) and simple - single color with no shading is better then realistic shading. Two color shading is acceptable, but does not seem to add to experience.
She (?) appears to consider shadows, 3d and other features of skeuomorphic design to be grown up, while more graphic, iconic flat design is childish.
That is a fairly unique interpretation...