Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system
by user9429450 on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @07:47PM
(#22489850)
I'm a hobbyist musician. I put some of my work on SoundCloud and license it CC no-commercial. A fan made a video to my work using public domain footage of various DNA processes. It happens to resemble the background of an old Bjork video. It was auto-striked as containing content belonging to her label due to the similarities in the video content. In reality they are violating MY copyright if the video happened to ever generate any revenue. I made an account just to post this. It's a sad situation.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system
by gnopgnip on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @08:44PM
(#22490164)
Generating revenue alone does not make it commercial use in the context of copyright
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system
by user9429450 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:25PM
(#22541592)
Correct, perhaps that is arguable, especially given the grey area this is all taking place in. I was speaking to the reality that if you're a popular YouTuber, and your content gets striked in this way, all revenues from that video go to them instead of you. This is especially terrible for music related content creators, fair use essentially does not exist for them.