News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by tptacek on Monday February 21, 2011 @09:40PM (#2248442)
One of the rare instances where we might be better served with a title different from that of the article. Even Matt Dillon probably wouldn't suggest U-Verse is a "complete failure" for normal people.

U-V (I hate this name) is AT&T's high-speed service; it's FTTN (fat pipe to a DSLAM in the alley) 10-15mb over phone copper. It's a triple-play service (you get your TV and phone over it). I know a bit about it because, uh, I have it.

Dillon is pissed because the U-V router/firewall, which you can't really replace, is so bad that it breaks power user configurations. He's right, it does. BitTorrent also chokes it (yay!). I can add other problems: the set-top boxes are flaky, the reliability isn't awesome, customer service is atrocious.

On the other hand: it is f-a-s-t and cheap. I had Comcast before it, and before that I had Speakeasy (who I'd been loyal to since before the Best Buy takeover until I couldn't ignore the terrible performance anymore). I wouldn't go back to any of them. I hear good things about Vzn's fiber service, but in Chicago, I think AT&T is the best available bet.

Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by w1ntermute on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:16PM (#2248543)
> Dillon is pissed because the U-V router/firewall, which you can't really replace, is so bad that it breaks power user configurations. He's right, it does.

I don't know which router you and he have, but the one I have (a 2wire, don't know the model details) is configured to DMZ a pfSense box. I can torrent, use Vonage (QoSed in pfSense), etc.

I agree that they have atrocious customer service (still having connectivity issues after numerous technician visits due to old/crappy last mile cabling), but what large ISP's don't?

Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by jedsmith on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @01:15AM (#2248986)
> (a 2wire, don't know the model details)

Probably 3800HG (V?), or something else in the 3000 series. I haven't been inside AT&T for many years, but Lightspeed/U-verse is all the 2wire 3000-series ("MediaPortal?" Fuzzy on that).

When I first started in IT I teched its regular DSL brother, the 2701. I still have one flashed with employee firmware, which unlocks what AT&T doesn't want you to have (parental controls and remote management and so on).

I say this without any former employee bias (my parting from Ma Bell was unsavory at best): the HomePortal line is a pretty solid device, for its target market. At least with traditional DSL if you don't dig the device (and if you know what QoS means, you won't), there's a plethora of other things out there. You can find something else to do gateway things, and the 2701 will act as solely a DSL modem if you ask it nicely.

Lightspeed/U-verse, though, well...

> I agree that they have atrocious customer service (still having connectivity issues after numerous technician visits due to old/crappy last mile cabling)

Finding an excuse to blame it on your in-house wiring, too?

Count your blessings, though, I'm in the same boat with Comcast and I pay per-visit unless I yell, which I hate doing because I've sat in that chair.

Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by w1ntermute on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @04:06PM (#2251571)
> Finding an excuse to blame it on your in-house wiring, too?

Actually, no. The technicians visited, looked at the in-house wiring, discovered new problems, looked at the last mile cabling, agreed it was in very poor shape, and then proceeded to replace only parts of it, most likely in order to save money. After several complaints, they've replaced the majority of it, but there are still times when the connection goes down.

Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by tptacek on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:46PM (#2248625)
From what I can tell, even the "DMZ" box has state table tracking; if you torrent from it (I will admit to torrenting TV shows that I pay for, even though this is an ethical gray-area), it still murders the Internet connection for everyone else.
Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by w1ntermute on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @12:23AM (#2248879)
The torrenting is QoSed as well, and while it's going on several devices are able to use the internet without any problems.
Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by fletchowns on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @04:15AM (#2249294)
I have the 2wire 3600hgv and it is garbage. Regularly requires a reboot and it will crash immediately if I try to transfer a file over ssh. The last 2wire modem I had from them, before I had U-Verse, would also crash when using ssh.
Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by bmelton on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:16PM (#2248544)
Vzn's fiber service is money. The router isn't particularly amazing (though competent) -- but the speed of the service is insanely fast and good all around.
Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by Malus on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:49PM (#2248795)
I have Verizon FiOS as well. As luck would have it, you are not required to use the router as your router (though I agree that the router is serviceable). I have an ethernet cable coming directly out of the FiOS ONT to my FreeBSD-based router. I use the Verizon router on my LAN as a MoCA bridge for my TV's set top box. Seems to work perfectly fine, though Verizon claims that their router is required for optimal QoS (I use ALTQ instead).
Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by abronte on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @01:53AM (#2249071)
Set top boxes are flaky? I've had quite the opposite experience. These have been the fastest, most responsive STB's I've ever worked with. Kicks the crap out of the Time Warner boxes.
Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by yesimahuman on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:54PM (#2248648)
Mine isn't f-a-s-t. It's just average. How much do you pay each month (just for internet)?
Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by tptacek on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:59PM (#2248662)
I don't remember; presumably second-from-the-top rate.
Re:AT&T U-Verse almost a complete failure by bretthoerner on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @01:27AM (#2249014)
24Mbps for $60/mo here, and I easily (and regularly) max that out.