Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance
by tptacek on Monday February 21, 2011 @09:01PM
(#2248302)
Let's keep perspective here. Because, your critique of the health insurance system seems to simultaneously affirm and entirely miss the point of the article.
A close read of your first three grafs --- the only ones that respond to the article --- suggests that you wish you could get something better than "car-crash-emergency" insurance for 50-100. Well. Let's unpack what you're missing here.
(1) The author of this article, like my own family, can't get "car-crash-emergency" insurance for 50, 100, or 500 dollars a month. Never mind the deductable. If your records include a shred of evidence of 150+ seemingly-random conditions†, you're an automatic decline. That's the problem the article is bringing up.
(2) A system in which only "car-crash-emergency" care was automatically covered would be workable; a vast improvement over what we have today! Outside of car crashes and appendicitis††, you in fact don't spend $1200/year on health care. We're a family of four, and we don't spend $1200/year on health care, let alone $4800/year or (gak) the significantly greater amount we really spend on the low-deductable group coverage we set up for Matasano.
A $5k deductable would suit us just fine; we'd save, significantly, simply by plowing the money we would have spent on crazy bullshit low-deductable insurance into an interest-bearing vehicle and shelling out from it when we actually needed care, all the while secure in the knowledge that when someone ends up in the ICU, our liability is capped. Not for nothing, but this is a scheme that both Dems and Republicans buy into.
Health care in America is broken. But it's not "utterly, utterly" broken. Whatever the number of random medical bk's we have in the US, it's too high. But we don't need to transform our health insurance system into the National Health or the French system. We are epsilon away from a Swiss-style system of mandatory and guaranteed-issue private insurance.
A close read of your first three grafs --- the only ones that respond to the article --- suggests that you wish you could get something better than "car-crash-emergency" insurance for 50-100. Well. Let's unpack what you're missing here.
(1) The author of this article, like my own family, can't get "car-crash-emergency" insurance for 50, 100, or 500 dollars a month. Never mind the deductable. If your records include a shred of evidence of 150+ seemingly-random conditions†, you're an automatic decline. That's the problem the article is bringing up.
(2) A system in which only "car-crash-emergency" care was automatically covered would be workable; a vast improvement over what we have today! Outside of car crashes and appendicitis††, you in fact don't spend $1200/year on health care. We're a family of four, and we don't spend $1200/year on health care, let alone $4800/year or (gak) the significantly greater amount we really spend on the low-deductable group coverage we set up for Matasano.
A $5k deductable would suit us just fine; we'd save, significantly, simply by plowing the money we would have spent on crazy bullshit low-deductable insurance into an interest-bearing vehicle and shelling out from it when we actually needed care, all the while secure in the knowledge that when someone ends up in the ICU, our liability is capped. Not for nothing, but this is a scheme that both Dems and Republicans buy into.
Health care in America is broken. But it's not "utterly, utterly" broken. Whatever the number of random medical bk's we have in the US, it's too high. But we don't need to transform our health insurance system into the National Health or the French system. We are epsilon away from a Swiss-style system of mandatory and guaranteed-issue private insurance.
† http://www.thecasongroup.com/forms/enrollment/Humana/H1%20Un... .
†† Many tens of thousands of dollars. Happened to a friend.