News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The growth of command-line options, 1979-Present by TeMPOraL on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @03:57AM (#22482182)
Fortunately, I'm in a very snarky mood today. I absolutely agree with those things you didn't tell me. And I do blame the "when we realized the simplest UX on mobile yielded the highest engagement" thing. I believe this to be the cause - people figured out that the ROI on shiny is better than ROI on building useful things, so most wide-audience software is now just garbage (and quite often a vehicle to scam users out of their personal data).

The market is allowed to exist because profit is a quite decent proxy for utility. But whenever you are optimizing using an imperfect proxy, it's possible to overoptimize - make the proxy metric look better, at the expense of the actual goal it was supposed to stand for. I believe software (along with much of other market sectors) have crossed that point a while ago.

Re:The growth of command-line options, 1979-Present by K0SM0S on Thursday March 05, 2020 @08:57AM (#22493501)
Indeed. The underlying economics (the harshness of no business model, i.e. no profit = wrong idea insofar as reality/markets won't have it) make it a very difficult proposition — sometimes I'm in awe at the fact that we could pull off "open source", that the idealism of that survived collision with reality long enough to demonstrate its value.

The economy to me is a vast "optimization space", so I can only agree. It's the 'trap' of a local minima I suppose, wherein the friction of moving away to find another possible (but uncertain) minima (hopefully overall lower or more acceptable ethically) is too high. So you've indeed overoptimized your way into a local pit (e.g. the ad model now taking over the news like a virus, resulting in this new "hybrid" object sometimes called "informercial" or "infotainment").

It seems that only "disruption" (of a magnitude worthy of the name) gives enough momentum to escape the steepness of a local historical/economical minima. Unless you've got some new S-curve (which quite literally may represent the math surface of this "escape path"), history tells us we remain stuck and move in circles about the center of 'gravity' of this local minima.

Dunno if that makes sense to you, pardon the loose physical analogies.