News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by ahkurtz on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @08:59PM (#22480575)
Maybe people have read it but don't think renaming "ideas" and "empathy" to "emotional contagion" is particularly groundbreaking or constructive.
Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by kick on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @09:09PM (#22480622)
The value of the paper is that it's where Facebook first started getting creative: a massive (N=689,00!), barely-consented-to (successful) attempt to sway the emotional states of hundreds of thousands of people.

That's both groundbreaking and constructive, if constructive in a way that harms people who don't have Facebook stock.

It set the stage for so much of what's happening today. Acting like it's just another boring paper is baffling.

Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by knzhou on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @09:31PM (#22480727)
> barely-consented-to (successful) attempt to sway the emotional states of hundreds of thousands of people

If you read the newspaper, watch TV, or read articles online, I have some bad news for you.

Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by groby_b on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @11:51PM (#22481295)
You miss a crucial part - none of this are individually tailored to you. Social media is the first form of media that can deliver an individually customized payload.
Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by inimino on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @09:40PM (#22480762)
Are you saying the paper itself is interesting, or that what the paper says about Facebook is interesting?

The actual result (people who see positive or negative messages are more likely to post the same) seems so obvious and uninteresting as not to be worth mentioning at all, though the fact that Facebook was willing to run the experiment and publish the result is perhaps more notable.

Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by disgruntledphd2 on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @08:47AM (#22483679)
The context at the time was that some authors were making the argument that seeing positive posts on FB increased negative affect.

This study, which was much larger, showed that this was not the case.

Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by inimino on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:03PM (#22488073)
Oh my. That would indeed be interesting, if only the method could even have a hope to show such a thing.

From the abstract:

> When positive expressions were reduced, people produced fewer positive posts and more negative posts; when negative expressions were reduced, the opposite pattern occurred.

Well and good, when people see more positive posts, they post more positively. But then:

> This work also suggests that, [...] the observation of others’ positive experiences constitutes a positive experience for people.

What a leap into the dark that is!

This study cannot show anything about affect, only about what was measured, which is what people posted on Facebook.

Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:17AM (#22511910)
Entirely agreed. But the previous study was a self-reported observational analysis, with appproximately 300 (German) participants.

I'm not defending the study in general, but the context of the research is somewhat important.

Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by omginternets on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @01:56AM (#22481734)
The subject is interesting, but there's barely any effect. Look at the d scores!

>a massive (N=689,00!)

Your critique reads like someone whose never done any research or serious statistical work. Big N's don't automatically mean the results are robust.

I'm sorry, this isn't the groundbreaking paper you want it to be.

Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by kick on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @02:19AM (#22481813)
Condescending remark aside, it's not important because of the effect or lack thereof; it's important because of how it was done.
Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by omginternets on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:39AM (#22495137)
Please consider that this stuff is very nuanced, and that while you clearly care about these issues a lot (as do I!), your analysis betrays a lack of understanding.

Any way you want to cut it, these results are not to be trusted. You cannot even be sure the conclusions are true. The effect sizes are within measurement error.

Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by anigbrowl on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @02:44AM (#22481897)
You can gmail me if you want a more receptive ear for your thoughts on this paper and related subject matter.
Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by tic_tac on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @09:37PM (#22480748)
It has an impact if singular events (of which there are millions each day) can severely affect social cohesion and stability. Regardless of what you call it, the inevitability of emotionally triggering events each of which has the potential to reach everyone in real time and impact them will lead to extreme social instability.

Similarly, too many unregulated synaptic connections or overexcited neurons in the brain can cause seizures.

How does it bode for society if, for example, every single instance of racial animosity between people is broadcast for the whole world to see? Even if the rate of occurrence of these sorts of interactions is incredibly small, there will be many per day, driving entire segments of our society apart and causing even more such negative interactions in the future which are just fuel for the fire.

Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by MockObject on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @11:38PM (#22481249)
Crime is down but reporting is up, and therefore fear is too.
Re:Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through soc... by raxxorrax on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:10AM (#22482236)
Just leave people a venue to vent. Trying to purify every platform made the problem much, much worse in my opinion.