So basically tar can behave normally (at least GNU tar can) -- it's just that there's an ancient idiom that most people have in their fingers, and that's copied around in various instructions.
The nice thing about the verbose way is that the hyphen prefix enables autocomplete.
This makes it easier to remember the syntax for create and list too:
That's how I write the install instructions for Oil:https://www.oilshell.org/release/0.8.pre2/doc/INSTALL.html
-----
So basically tar can behave normally (at least GNU tar can) -- it's just that there's an ancient idiom that most people have in their fingers, and that's copied around in various instructions.
The nice thing about the verbose way is that the hyphen prefix enables autocomplete.