News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by mathieuh on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @02:47AM (#22472633)
He can go to Mars and stay.

I don’t understand why so many people just accept the rhetoric of Musk and Gates, so-called “liberal capitalists” (liberal in the modern meaning, not classical liberal).

They made their money through exploiting other people’s labour, that’s the only way you accumulate such capital.

They then go on to donate a vanishingly small amount relatively to recognisable, bleeding-heart-liberal causes and everything they did to get here is forgotten and forgiven.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by wilg on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @03:05AM (#22472731)
> They made their money through exploiting other people’s labour, that’s the only way you accumulate such capital.

Is that true? Maybe, but I guess it hinges on your definition of "exploit". I think you can make money (in theory, of any amount) without exploiting people.

> They then go on to donate a vanishingly small amount

Haven't they both pledged to donate 99% in their lifetimes? Plus you could argue the companies themselves (where at least Musk's wealth is mostly locked up) are helpful. At least Tesla.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by econcon on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @04:46AM (#22473118)
>Is that true? Maybe, but I guess it hinges on your definition of "exploit". I think you can make money (in theory, of any amount) without exploiting people

There would be no excess for the founder if you distribute all the money that a company operation makes evenly to all employees and owners.

That's what they mean when they summon the world "exploit".

Roman slaves weren't exploited in the ways some layman might imagine.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by vzcx on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @11:21AM (#22475855)
Founders are typically the first and primary owners, at least initially... Is the objection that founders and investors get a larger slice?

People have a strange reaction to the word 'exploit.' It smells bad, and it gives the sense that those using the term want something to smell bad.

'Exploit' just means 'to make productive use of' to me. Musk 'exploited' his workers? Good. Theyre making cool stuff. That's what he should be doing. A company 'exploited' a uranium deposit? Good. We need those hot rocks for fuel rods.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by econcon on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @10:16PM (#22480917)
I also own a company but many times who work for us often have similar ideas like "owners are taking too much, they are stealing from us".
Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by stuaxo on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @03:52AM (#22472927)
By taking a bigger % of the work put in than the person doing the work == exploiting.
Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by diffeomorphism on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @04:13AM (#22473000)
So any management position is exploitation? Being the boss of any manufacturing business is exploitation?

Hint: Even if you take only 1% of the work but employ 1000 people you are going to get rich.

Your benchmark for what is exploiting seems to not work particularly well in practice.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by samcday on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @05:01AM (#22473186)
> So any management position is exploitation? Being the boss of any manufacturing business is exploitation?

In many peoples opinion (including mine), yes. This can all be considered wage slavery.

Of course the magnitude and severity varies. A worker in the Gigafactory (probably) has a higher standard of living than the one in the Foxconn factory, who in turn probably has a better standard of living than the worker in the Nike sweatshop. But it’s all the same thing.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by virgilp on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:26AM (#22473541)
> wage slavery

Also called a "job". You're telling me I'm a wage slave? (in the last 10 years nobody reported to me, I was never self-employed).

Through this sort of wage slavery in the last 10years, I have achieved an incredibly high standard of living, compared to the regular citizens of any age in human history. I think this narrative is just devaluing the meaning of words and the suffering of those who really are exploited.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by nicoburns on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:51AM (#22473638)
A lot of people (even in first-world countries) have zero chance of becoming a multi-millionaire, and even struggle to make ends meet, pay their rent, etc. That is the problem, not highly compensated workers.

And it is an economic system which awards a vastly disproportionate share of resources to people like Musk and Gates that deprives others of those same resources.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by virgilp on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @07:10AM (#22473732)
Yes, that is true (though at the same time things have been massively improving in average). What I find amazing is that we live in a time where a person living in a (relatively) poor country, working a non-management job, paying all taxes, _can_ actually get fairly rich. Employment really isn't "slavery".

Would it be great if more people could achieve prosperity - ideally, _all_ people? Yes it would. However, just "take the money of the rich" is not a solution for this (we can argue about details of taxation, and I don't think in particular USA has a good system, but that's more of "fine-grain detail" in the end)

> it is an economic system which awards a vastly disproportionate share of resources to people like Musk and Gates that deprives others of those same resources.

I've lived in communism. It really is equal sharing of misery, _not_ equal sharing of reward. The reality is that Musk really puts in way more effort & takes a lot more risk than your average factory worker. But at the end of the day - not even that is what matters. What matters is that by attempting this "equal sharing of resources", each and every time it was tried, it resulted in a horrible dystopia. Not sure what it would take to convince people it's an inherently bad idea - but I feel that at least by now the burden of proof should be on the shoulder of those who advocate it.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by nicoburns on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @11:49AM (#22476170)
> just "take the money of the rich" is not a solution for this

I'm not suggesting taking money from the rich. I'm suggesting not giving it to them in the first place.

> What matters is that by attempting this "equal sharing of resources", each and every time it was tried, it resulted in a horrible dystopia.

I'm also not suggesting "equal sharing of resources". The idea that the only possible distributions of wealth are "everyone gets the same" and "unbounded in response to supply/demand" is silly. If all the billionaires in the world had $10million instead of $1 billion, and everyone with >$1million's wealth was scaled down in proportion, I'd be happy. There'd still be plenty to work for.

For me, the key issue with communism was too much concentrated power. That lead to inefficient resource distribution, because the people responsible for distributing had perverse incentives which lead to corruption, and even where the leadership was benevolent, they simply didn't have the mental resources to work out how best to distribute things.

Now, markets solve this problem, by allowing everyone to have input into what the economy produces, simply by spending their own share of our economic output. However, this mechanism relies on economic demand being somewhat evenly spread out amongst the population. Otherwise you end up with the same problem: those in control of demand have incentives to pursue their own self-interest, and even where they are benevolent, they don't have the means to determine efficient distribution.

Bill Gate's philanthropy is a good example of this: very well meaning, but hopelessly ineffective given the huge sums of money involved. Notably, this wealth is being distributed just like wealth in communist countries: in a planned way, by a central authority. Extreme wealth concentration circumvents the market mechanism, and should be avoided for just the same reasons as communism.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by virgilp on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @12:39PM (#22476743)
But nobody gave them the money! Take eg Bezos - Amazon is textbook example of wealth creation, in the economic sense (lowered the prices, thus people could afford more). His wealth is not "given", it's created! How do you control the distribution of that wealth, other than tax, in a way that doesn't destroy the very mechanism that made it possible?

(honest question, it feels like you have an answer; I just don't see it)

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by nicoburns on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @01:37PM (#22477406)
I am suggesting taxation. I'm just pointing out that the idea that taxation "takes away" wealth that people have "earned" pre-supposes an economic system (and ultimately a moral system - think about what it really means to earn something: it means to deserve it) where money accrues to those who perform certain actions (such as selling goods). It perfectly consistent to have an economic system where the rule is that beyond a certain point, you only accrue a portion of the value given by the person obtaining the good.

What is money, other than the power to get others to perform economic activity for you, backed by the state? It is given by it's very nature.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by virgilp on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @03:07PM (#22478272)
But taxation is "taking money" as opposed to "not giving it in the first place". These are not people who take a salary - if you tax the company into oblivion so that "it doesn't make money in the first place", then you stop the wealth creation. If you tax the transfer from the company to the individual... well, you need to be much more specific on how you do that in a way that is not making them look wealthy. Also, this form of taxation will not ensure equitable distribution of wealth to the contributors of the enterprise (i.e. Amazon warehouse employees would still be "wage slaves") - just redistribution to the general population (and just redistribution, not "equitable redistribution", because that would be too hard a problem to solve). Now don't get me wrong - I am e.g. in favor of "basic income" and think we should strive to offer a decent minimum standard of living to everyone. But it's a big jump from there to "we should prevent people from getting _too_ rich" - both these are initiatives that have some merit and some downsides, but I don't think one helps the other in any meaningful way.

(as a side note, I disagree both that Bill Gates' philanthropy is "hopelessly ineffective" or that the rich drive demand - but these are two long discussions/debates in and of themselves)

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by diffeomorphism on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @11:07AM (#22475666)
> But it’s all the same thing.

"If everything is important, nothing is."

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by collyw on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @05:51AM (#22473387)
Some work is more valuable than other work.
Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by newsgremlin on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:05AM (#22473445)
But by margins of billions? Figures like this are thrown around a lot but it's hard to grasp how much just one billion, even 1/1000 of that can make an individuals life unrecognizable before having that wealth.
Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by modo_mario on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:09AM (#22473460)
>Haven't they both pledged to donate 99% in their lifetimes?

Didn't gates massively increase his wealth in the period in which he said he'd give away half of it?

>Plus you could argue the companies themselves (where at least Musk's wealth is mostly locked up) are helpful. At least Tesla.

But would they exist without him? He's certainly been good at marketing himself and by extension his companies. On the other hand he also just bought the rights to the title founder at tesla so the actual original founders can't call themselves that which many people don't seem to realize. Meanwhile they kept hostage battery tech advantage via Panasonic. And then there's spacex and Solar city which happily survived on tax payer funds whilst the later maybe didn't help green energy adoption as much as a competitor might have in it's stead as they basically did Chinese solar panel resale which were going at dumping prices and the EU was blocking for that rezason....And i think they also had/have some fun gov bribery accusations against em which reflects badly on the billions in taxpayer subsidies they managed to waste. Meanwhile whilst an increase in NASA's budget wasn't politically feasible it's been a notoriously monetarily efficient institution.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by 101404 on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @05:28AM (#22473295)
They made their money by providing tools that saved others a lot of money.

It's not 1850 anymore.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by roenxi on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:21AM (#22473517)
> They made their money through exploiting other people’s labour, that’s the only way you accumulate such capital.

What alternative do you want to see? Perhaps a world where everyone is using linux and everyone compiles their own software?

It isn't a laughable idea, but the idea that if the labour hadn't been exploited we'd be better off is not a good one. If labour isn't exploited it is wasted; it isn't like programmers or mechanics are a special breed of person who appeared in the modern era. These people are the same people we've always had and the evidence is we get much better results when working within a corporate structure. There wasn't and isn't a law saying that Musk and Gates had to own the the corporations. If workers want co-ops I'm sure they'd manage.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by nicoburns on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:48AM (#22473627)
Nobody wants the labour not to occur. But some of us want the fruits of that labour to be more evenly distributed. That could be as simple as keeping a corporate structure, but taxing it more aggressively and/or raising minimum wages.
Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by de_watcher on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:17AM (#22473496)
Don't lump Musk and Gates together.
Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by 101404 on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:50AM (#22473634)
Very true.

Gates made his money using very shady tactics at the cost of the consumer. Now he uses that money to buy himself a favorable place in the history books by doing things that don't help but look good.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @09:59AM (#22474924)
> Gates made his money using very shady tactics at the cost of the consumer.

In part, but the other part of that is making software that vastly increased human productivity with a computer at an incredibly competitive price point.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by 101404 on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @11:02AM (#22475617)
And destroying other software that increased productivity using pretty shady methods.

But it's interesting to see that his "old image" already almost vanished. His strategy to "do things that look good" seems to work. Humans have very short memories after all.

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by lawlessone on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:54AM (#22473647)
> Now he uses that money to buy himself a favorable place in the history

I agree

>doing things that don't help but look good

I disagree, they seem to do a lot for vaccinations

Re:British billionaire Hohn launches campaign to starve coal... by 101404 on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @08:32AM (#22474270)
Yes, it looks good. They spend a lot of money.

But, if you look at all the countries that have successfully won the fight against malaria (many Latin American countries, southern US, southern EU, etc): it wasn't because of vaccines but because of good public administration.

Anyway, sure it's good that money goes to vaccines research. But so far it only looks good. They also spend money on other areas.