The point I think you are missing is that Klout, and other ranking systems, can give a quick and objective assessment of someone's value or ability in a certain area.
Here's a list of ranking systems and what they indicate:
Klout -> online influence StackOverflow -> programming expertise FourSquare -> loyalty to a business Credit Score -> fiscal responsibility HackerNews Karma -> ability to provide interesting and pertinent points of conversation
My "online influence" has zero effect on my professional or personal life, and I suspect the same is true for many other software engineers. That's the point I was making, and the author's first erroneous sentence is roughly where I stopped reading what he had to say.
People with blogs and StackOverflow profiles public expose how much they actually know about software development. Then when they have a greater following or more points that is a validation that what are saying is accurate.
I have not checked my Klout score, and indeed until just now had no idea what Klout actually was. When I looked at Klout's homepage, it requires a Twitter account to search for someone. I don't use Twitter and I know I'm not the only one, so I think this is pretty bogus as far as a reputation measurement goes.
I don't know how how this guy has decided that means I'm in an online minority, but I do know that his Bartonphink score just took a dip.