News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Home was not where the heart was for the Enlightenment’s ... by Mediterraneo10 on Sunday March 01, 2020 @12:45PM (#22457995)
Can you cite the claim that Abaris came from Mongolia? Whoever would make such a claim is speaking far too confidently. The details provided in the actual Greek sources are ambiguous and could apply to anywhere in northern Eurasia.
Re:Home was not where the heart was for the Enlightenment’s ... by dr_dshiv on Sunday March 01, 2020 @03:16PM (#22459000)
Yes! Def. It is Peter Kingsley's new book, "a story waiting to pierce you". It is very, very good.
Re:Home was not where the heart was for the Enlightenment’s ... by Mediterraneo10 on Sunday March 01, 2020 @03:34PM (#22459118)
Alright, I see. I hope you understand that this book, published in New Age circles, is a not a reputable work on history or even a reasonable pop-sci distillation thereof. Consequently, I feel it is irresponsible to make the claim in the post above.
Re:Home was not where the heart was for the Enlightenment’s ... by dr_dshiv on Monday March 02, 2020 @02:45AM (#22462475)
Not so! Kinglsey is a great scholar and respected as such. This book is extremely well referenced -- more than half the book is notes and references. It also has a blurb from Walter Burkett just before he died. Yes, it's not standard history -- and he takes a spiritual perspective. But it is extremely appropriate for the subject matter.

Impuning the book because it is published in new age circles is unfair. I recommend refreshing your perspective by reading "esotericism in the academy" by Wouter Hanagraaf. Or, "western esotericism: a guide for the perplexed"

Re:Home was not where the heart was for the Enlightenment’s ... by Mediterraneo10 on Monday March 02, 2020 @11:47AM (#22466041)
> Kinglsey is a great scholar and respected as such

He is not however respected as a historian or archaeologist of Northern Eurasia, which would allow him to claim that any figure in Greek history came specifically from Mongolia. If he says in the book that this is merely his own speculation, that would be fine, but the fact is that speculation is all it would be.

> I recommend refreshing your perspective by reading "esotericism in the academy" by Wouter Hanagraaf. Or, "western esotericism: a guide for the perplexed"

Esoteric philosophy and its validity or lack thereof is irrelevant to the historical–archaeological claim that you made in your post above.

Re:Home was not where the heart was for the Enlightenment’s ... by dr_dshiv on Monday March 02, 2020 @12:29PM (#22466532)
> Esoteric philosophy and its validity or lack thereof is irrelevant to the historical–archaeological claim that you made in your post above.

I mentioned the work on esotericism in history in reference to the dismissal of kinglsey on the basis of new age affiliation.

And speculation can be essential for creating plausible narratives in a world with limited data. But I agree, speculation should always be labeled!

Re:Home was not where the heart was for the Enlightenment’s ... by dr_dshiv on Monday March 02, 2020 @02:54AM (#22462508)
Posting Kingsley's Wikipedia as an intro: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Kingsley_(scholar)
Re:Home was not where the heart was for the Enlightenment’s ... by dr_dshiv on Monday March 02, 2020 @06:41AM (#22463564)
And, to be clear, I'm not referring to the country of Mongolia today, but to the extent of the historical culture of the nomadic people of the steppes.