News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The unspoken truth about managing geeks (2009) by looping__lui on Sunday March 01, 2020 @02:23AM (#22455630)
This sounds like a dysfunctional company to me.

If somebody is a kick-ass programmer AND understands what value he is adding - he will be very successful at the company I am working right now. If he disagrees with his manager AND is right even more so.

But the experience I made is that the “feedback and speaking” up is more driven by personal preference and “what do I want to work on” instead of business and customer need.

Re:The unspoken truth about managing geeks (2009) by perl4ever on Sunday March 01, 2020 @09:42PM (#22461180)
"This sounds like a dysfunctional company to me."

Well, I hesitate to call something "dysfunctional" if it works. It becomes a subjective value judgment.

Different companies have succeeded in different ways.

Re:The unspoken truth about managing geeks (2009) by looping__lui on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @01:48PM (#22477533)
This does sound dysfunctional in a way that decision making is obviously happening more compartmentalized and individual ownership is severely limited.

There is a reason why many super successful companies have values/culture: shift ownership and decision making as much to the people at the forefront as possible to avoid “managing them from the top”.

Empowering engineers and scientists to develop a sense and say in product priorities is great, extremely difficult but speaks for a company that values contributions beyond a “specialization/niche”