News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by jdkee on Saturday February 29, 2020 @02:53PM (#22452621)
So the U.S. lost, like the Soviets, like the British, etc.

Graveyard of empires.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by chewz on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:26PM (#22452845)
Actually there were many more successful conquerors of Afganistan (Greco-Baktrian Kingdon, Mauryan Empire, Kushan Empire, Sassanian Empire, Ghaznavids, Mongol Empire, Timurid Empire, Mughal Empire and Safavid Empire to name just a few) then failed ones.

Alexander of Macedon[2], British, Soviets and now USA have failed because they all have had unrealistic objectives.

But Afghanistan had been ruled by "foreign" rulers for most of it's history. They all had one thing in common - they have kept multiple forces in balance and limited their rule to the capital.

> He shows how governing these peoples was relatively easy when power was concentrated in a small dynastic elite, but how this delicate political order broke down in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries when Afghanistan's rulers mobilized rural militias to expel first the British and later the Soviets. Armed insurgency proved remarkably successful against the foreign occupiers, but it also undermined the Afghan government's authority and rendered the country ever more difficult to govern as time passed.

> Afghanistan is essential reading for anyone who wants to understand how a land conquered and ruled by foreign dynasties for more than a thousand years became the "graveyard of empires" for the British and Soviets, and what the United States must do to avoid a similar fate.

Afghanistan: A Cultural and Political History by Thomas Barfield [1]

[1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7718203-afghanistan

> Recounting the plight of the most powerful leader of the time as he led the most sophisticated army of its day into the treacherous world of tribal warlords, Holt describes those grueling campaigns and the impact they had on Alexander, his generals, their troops, and the world. Into the Land of Bones also examines the conflict from the point of view of the local warlords who pushed the invading Greeks to the limits of their endurance—and sometimes beyond, into mania and mutiny.

[2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1584212.Into_the_Land_of...

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by boznz on Saturday February 29, 2020 @02:58PM (#22452657)
What was there ever to win?
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by unlinked_dll on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:15PM (#22452765)
Well that's the reason the War on Terror is such a stupid concept. There was no win condition, because we never defined one or stuck to it.

As Kissinger pointed out in World Order (love or hate the man, it's a good read) - military force is a political tool to achieve political goals. And just like Kissinger's abject failure to achieve any meaningful political goals other than endless, meaningless war and death, it's because he could never define goals that could be achieved in the first place.

And that's the story of American foreign policy in the middle east. Our leaders and political theorists can't even agree on what goals should be or even goals that can be reached - just meaningless diatribe about "presence" and "if we're not there someone else will step in."

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by throwaway22920 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:41PM (#22452952)
Not just the middle east, but the world over. We can't have normal relations with Cuba because they're repressive, yet we'll sell weapons to Vietnam? Politicians get maligned for simply meeting with Bashar al-Assad, but selling weapons to Saudi Arabia gets met with a shrug? The political establishment in the U.S., usually backed by the media, pushes a nonsensical foreign policy that's often against U.S. interests. Turning Iraq, Libya, and Syria into failed states runs contrary to just about any goal you can imagine for the U.S., but the political and media establishment decided to go at it full bore for whatever reason.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by unlinked_dll on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:53PM (#22453775)
I think you missed my point, which was that the wars in the Middle East failed because we didn't have clear political objectives. That's not true in the other examples you listed, we have pretty clear goals as it relates to the Saudis and Cubans. With respect to Libya and Syria we're more sideline players but the goals are still fairly clear.

If you try and apply a consistent morality onto geopolitics you're going to see everyone is hypocritical. But geopolitics is not a debate between philosophers on morality and political theory. It's applied game theory closer to what Sun Tzu wrote than Hobbes or Locke.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by nradov on Saturday February 29, 2020 @11:16PM (#22455079)
Vietnam is now seen as an essential military ally to encircle and contain China.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pbhjpbhj on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:18AM (#22456215)
I think if you say "often against the non-ruling population of USA's interests", then you might find a reason why the elite still sell arms to both sides.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pjc50 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:58PM (#22453803)
The US can't have normal relations with Cuba because the families of those who fled are swing voters in Florida. Whereas nobody cares about Vietnam and they're now a fairly normal far east state (effectively one-party, but so is Singapore) and communist in name only like China.

> Turning Iraq, Libya, and Syria into failed states runs contrary to just about any goal you can imagine for the U.S

All of them had publicly defied the US at some point. It's the insult that matters to the establishment.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pbhjpbhj on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:22AM (#22456227)
How much profit did some major USA companies make out of Iraq? Are you sure it's "for honor"?
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by kazen44 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:32PM (#22453659)
> Well that's the reason the War on Terror is such a stupid concept. There was no win condition.

What if the win condition is actually having a constant percieved threat, and thus a war to act on said threat.

From someone not from the US, american politics is dominated with who is right and who is wrong. The entire political spectrum seems to be divided between "winners and losers" and the politics seem very black and white compared to my experience with politics from other countries.

What if the wars the US have started are merely a political tool to rally the population for party support?

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by unlinked_dll on Saturday February 29, 2020 @06:24PM (#22453939)
The thing you're observing is the stubbornness and arrogance derived from the rugged individualism that defines the American identity. It's not that politics is about who is right and who is wrong, but the notion that any individual always believes they are right. It's not about being a winner or a loser, but being the good guy in your own narrative - others be damned. There's this very deep divide between that mindset that we respect as Americans and the utility of those that exemplify it being in positions of leadership in a representative democracy.

The problem is that those that get elected or rise through the ranks of military and our government tend to be the exact people that shouldn't. That's not necessarily just an American thing, since selfish and proud people exist everywhere.

What it leads to is not some conspiracy to keep endless wars going to stay in power. To the contrary, the endless wars are a product of the continuous flux of people who believe they are right and arrogantly refuse to believe they can be wrong at all. If you speak with those in the civil service or those educated by our thought leaders in foreign policy, a consistent notion in why we continue these pointless wars is not because we have some absolute objective. It's because we believe that if we aren't there, someone else will be, and better us than them. That is the deep arrogance and stubbornness of America at work, that we are always right, even in spite of all the evidence to the contrary.

Sorry for the rambling. It's just that some of this deeply upsets me and I've had this debate many times with family members and friends who have more direct influence and experience.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pjc50 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:40PM (#22452943)
Revenge for 9/11?

Of course, since OBL was being sheltered in Pakistan by the Pakistani intelligence service ISI, and much of the support for extreme Islamism was coming from Saudi Arabia (as were some of the hijackers), and those countries were untouchable, the reprisals had to be carried out against the two Arab Muslim countries that were least popular with the US instead.

(Much of the supplies for Afghanistan had to be driven across a thousand miles of lawless Pakistani frontier and were occasionally attacked there; the Afghan occupation was also hampered by being unable to pursue or fire across the Pakistani border.)

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by x0re4x on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:12PM (#22452737)
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by ccsnags on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:11PM (#22452732)
That was the issue the whole time. There were no defined conditions of victory.

On the ground, victory or defeat weren’t on the table. When we were there, we just wanted to come home in one piece.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by jjoonathan on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:12PM (#22452740)
Military-industrial dollars from the US taxpayers?
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by smackay on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:13PM (#22452751)
It's probably strategically important, particularly with regards to China's Belt and Road Initiative, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by polotics on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:06PM (#22452703)
The prize would have been a massive reduction in opium production. Nowadays with most US OD deaths being on Chinese synthetics and lobbyist-supported Sackler shit, the landscape's evolved a tad.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by ccsnags on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:13PM (#22452747)
This was never a priority.

In fact, they increased production and got a host of veterans hooked on the junk.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by alfiedotwtf on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:24PM (#22452826)
Military contracts
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by arminiusreturns on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:31PM (#22453657)
If I gave you an honest answer you probably wouldnt believe it, nor would others, and I'd be called many names (as has happened before).

Truth is treason in an empire of lies.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by selimthegrim on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:41PM (#22453715)
You might as well.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by arminiusreturns on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:44PM (#22459919)
I initially wrote a response about why it isn't worth it. Many downsides and not as many upsides, but on second thought I realized I was prejudging the HN community and I don't like that I was doing that. Considering this is a day old and probably only people particularly interested in the topic are still reading, I'll give a go.

I'm not fully sure how to structure this, so I'm just going to dive into a list of potential answers to the original question: What was/is there to win? While I am aiming at the question about Afghanistan, general region topics and Iraq factor in very much as well.

1. Destabilization: Much of the problem in the GWOT was and is due to the confusion of purpose. Some saw it as to defeat Al Qaeda. Some as revenge for 9/11 (despite the fact that most of the hijackers were Saudi Wahhabists, even if they had been in the Afghan training camps. That eventually evolved over time to issues with the Taliban, and it's various networks like the Haqqani and the Quetta councils in Pakistan. The problem is that while certain groups like the military leadership (such as Petraeus) bought into this, they didn't understand or weren't empowered to counter the underlying desire for instability at the political and above level. When I say above I mean what I call the political "shadow players", the ones that exist through multiple presidencies and have a huge influence over top-down decision trees in government. I like to use Zbigniew Brzezinski and Henry Kissinger as prime examples. They in turn influenced the top level political entities to make moves often counter to the surface purpose of the war(s). A great example of this would be when Ian Bremmer and Rumsfeld, despite protestation from the military, decided to tell the Iraqi commander with 40k troops asking what to do with them to go fuck off. In the end, much of actions of that type were very much geared towards keeping things unstable, for reasons I will go into further, and it's worth noting that's pretty much exactly what has happened.

2. Containment: Let's be frank. Iran is sandwiched in between Iraq and Afghanistan and it has been in the crosshairs for quite some time now. Also worth remembering in context is that much of Saddams power was increased when we quietly backed him in the Iran-Iraq war. The joke on the ground used to be "How do we know Saddam has WMDs? Because we still have the receipts!" Not much actually changed from the 90's and destabilization of the region plays into keeping Iran busy there instead of elsewhere such as in Lebanon and Syria, at least to a degree. It's more than that, but Iran is the main target of containment. It also was used as a draw to get fighters to show up there instead of in western countries, another form of containment. Lots of foreign fighters started showing up the body count.

3. Presence: By establishing and expanding the middle east and western asian connections, infrastructure, bases, etc, we have closer inroads for conflicts in the future, and that's not even necessarily geared towards ME countries. It could be China, Russia, Africa, etc. Africa in particular happened to play this out with Libya, Sudan, etc, and it continues to this day.

4. Combat hardiness: at a more Machiavellian level, the relatively tame conflict(s) on blue-side were seen as a good proving ground to refine modern combat techniques, tools, tactics and strategies. Lots of think-tank analysis after the fact to help gear up towards conflicts in a future that might be more tri-polar conflict likely. It's a dirty business to be a general and have to think like that, but it is what it is.

5. Black markets: Just as in Vietnam, the destabilization and control offered a great opportunity for certain organizations to participate in black markets. See, for example, congress is supposed to have purse string control of the CIA... but if they can pull some Iran-Contra esque gun-drug running on a suddenly booming opium producing country that has almost no rule of law and is swarming with military who don't ask too many questions, they can essentially remove themselves from congressional oversight. Just look at the growth of the opioid epidemic in America in time with Afghanistan. Ignoring the pharma part, a huge percentage of tested heroin in America traces it's origins too... yep, Afghanistan. It's an age old playbook the 3-letters have been using for a while. (Cocaine cowboys like Barry Seal into Arkansas... who was the governor there again?)

6. Kickbacks: You also have to realize that a lot of the policy influencers tend to be old white guys who own or on the boards of defense companies in Virginia (or oil companies like Halliburton), and those good ol boys have lots of power. Lots of what happened was just plain old money laundering from taxpayers/the treasury into their pockets. There is a reason a few counties in Virginia have had the highest growth of millions in the country since the GWOT started.

7. Resource control: along with presence and control of these places, comes the ability to influence resource flow routes (and who gets those contracts, see above). This is one of the most important and oft overlooked aspects of the whole thing. See cries that the wars were about us taking the oil weren't quite true. It was more about controlling who the oil did go to. Even in the modern context a lot of the action in say Syria has a lot of hidden resource control route justifications the public never hears about. On the Afghanistan side one thing it does is help prevent natural gas and oil from reaching China to the east and Russia to the north. I saw the current Russia-gate hysteria coming many years ago because the shadow players like ZB telegraphed it so much... always talking about the return to a tri-polar world.

8. Banking: Banks and economies tend to boom in times of war (until the war is over and things contract, or if you are in the country the war actually happens in). This is also highly under-analyzed.

9. The elephant(s) in the room: Israel and Suadi Arabia. Much of the actions in ME have been due to a large level of influence they both have over policy makers in the US. Many of the above reasons seem to benefit them more than the US, especially when the repeat blowback comes home to roost in another 20 years.

10. Destruction of rights at home: when the people cried out for a response, the military congressional academic think-tank complex immediately used the opportunity to further undermine individual rights at home. They have constantly moved the overton window further and further towards acceptance of a dystopian semi-totalitarian state. Just look at any topic in HN, a forum full of hackers, to see the excuses and servile placations for these things. There are multiple reasons, some of which are a bit over the top to get into, but the more reasonable justification is that technology has changed the threat model away from nation states and more and more towards single actors being able to pull off big things (bio-engineering, infrastructure hacking, etc). Many of the MICC/good ol boys in DC/VA buy into this reasoning on the surface, despite really understanding they are undermining the foundational principles of America (and lining their pockets at the same time). A prime example of this would be William Binney's report that he had designed a surveillance program called ThinThread that would have protected American's privacy and still enabled the gov to track threats, and implimentation would costed in the 10s of millions. The program was scrapped in favor of a multi-billion dollar program that didn't protect Americans privacy and lost threats in the haystack of information.

Just a few off the top of my head. Hanlon's razor just can't account for all these things. Yes incompetence runs rampant, but incompetence in these cases is often just as bad as malice, or is easily manipulable by those with malice.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by nkurz on Sunday March 01, 2020 @08:31PM (#22460805)
Brilliant response, thanks for taking the time to write it up! Realize that the community here is not a fixed quantity. If you lead with high effort comments like this, eventually the community might return the favor. Unfortunately, I don't understand the politics here enough to personally offer any useful critique. If you don't get the feedback you want here, posting a version of this to an Open Thread on Slate Star Codex might start a good conversation.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by arminiusreturns on Monday March 02, 2020 @02:16AM (#22462355)
Hadn't heard of Slate Star Codex, thanks for both that and the kind comment.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pixxel on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:05PM (#22452695)
Presence.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by sytelus on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:53PM (#22453390)
-
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by boomboomsubban on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:59PM (#22453814)
>back on to achieve the same objectives they were in 2000.

Sovereignty and economic stability for their communities? Or do you imagine their goal involves hurting the West rather than improving their lives?

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by dx87 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:07PM (#22452709)
Have the country run by a secular government, not a theocratic one.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by platz on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:12PM (#22452743)
regime change doesn't work
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by arcticbull on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:30PM (#22452873)
That's an overly broad statement, I think we have plenty of examples from history where it did work. I'd say it worked fine in WWII Germany.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pjc50 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:59PM (#22453810)
Germany and Japan were mono-ethnic industrial states that largely didn't have anyone sabotaging the reconstruction, and Germany had the disadvantage of being split in half; everyone wanted to surrender to the US, because the alternative was the Soviet Union.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by eropple on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:36PM (#22452912)
Total defeat tends to do that, yeah. A better description might be that resisted regime change usually doesn’t work. Which is certainly not unfair with regards to Afghanistan.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by platz on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:09PM (#22453126)
The next time we're in a world war I'll grant your point

Can we talk about things that happened in the last 70 years please

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by AnimalMuppet on Saturday February 29, 2020 @06:30PM (#22453970)
If we had rebuilt Iraq like we did Germany and Japan, it probably would have worked. We could have created a secular, democratic state. We would have had to keep several hundred thousand troops there for a decade or more to make it happen, though, and there wasn't the political will to do so.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pbhjpbhj on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:29AM (#22456251)
Is building a massive military control zone down the middle of a country "success"? So Korea, at the moment, is success and the Berlin Wall divided Germany was success?
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by AnimalMuppet on Sunday March 01, 2020 @07:37PM (#22460512)
Japan was definitely success. We changed the culture enough that they never reappeared as a military threat, to ourselves or anyone else.

Germany was a success as well. We changed a culture that had war as an ingrained part into one that has been peaceful for generations. And the Berlin Wall was not the fault of America or the west.

As for Korea... we continue to be there, not because we're trying to change their culture, but because we are trying to deter invasion from North Korea.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by apta on Sunday March 01, 2020 @02:56AM (#22455731)
It's quite egregious how the US thinks it has the right to force a regime change in any state it chooses, and that "secular" and "democratic" is always the answer. This is an extremely Western biased, and sorry to say, extremely ignorant way of thinking.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by AnimalMuppet on Sunday March 01, 2020 @07:45PM (#22460561)
First of all, I didn't say that the US had the right to force a regime change on anyone it chose. You're reading that into my comment. I only said that, if we wanted to actually change a place like Iraq, we couldn't do it "on the cheap" like we tried to do.

Back in World War II, we didn't initiate the "forcing". Once we won, what did you want us to do? Leave Germany and Japan to nurse their grievances, rebuild their militaries, and come back 20 years later for another round? (Note the pattern of Germany between World Wars I and II.) Having won, we (quite rightly in my view) decided that they were going to be transformed. Don't want your society transformed by outsiders by force? Don't start wars with them that you're going to lose in the end.

If you want to say that Iraq is a less justified case, I might agree. If you want to say that going to war to remove him was the wrong thing to do, that's a reasonable position. But having removed him, what should we do next? Just help the people set up any semblance of a government, and walk away?

It may be that secular can't work in some place like Iraq. That's possible. It may be that democratic can't work, either, not without preparing people for a generation. But what would you shoot for instead? Who should be the non-democratic leader, and why should it be them? And why do you think that way would work better?

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by apta on Monday March 02, 2020 @11:59AM (#22466199)
> Don't want your society transformed by outsiders by force? Don't start wars with them that you're going to lose in the end.

Iraq was invaded by the US and its allies, especially in 2003, under the guise of baseless WMD. Yet, the political leaders in the US and its allies never faced any ramifications for their actions, that directly resulted in the deaths and mutilations of hundreds of thousands of people over time. But hey, they're just "brown people", so who cares, right?

> not without preparing people for a generation

"Preparing" meaning brainwashing, correct? Again, what gives the US the right to "prepare" people of other states and countries, especially since we see the failures of US-style "democracy" and "secularism". Face the facts, people in the Middle East are generally conservative and religious, and they don't see Western style democracy or secularism as a solution, particularly when many aspects of those directly contradict their religion and culture. Furthermore, we saw what happens when the local population elects someone not in line with US's interests (see Morsi, etc.).

The US is now forced to declare peace with the Taliban, after all it's put Afghanistan and its people through. Countless lives and trillions of dollars later, and it's back to where things started (almost).

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by AnimalMuppet on Monday March 02, 2020 @03:30PM (#22468580)
I'll say this again, since you seem to have ignored it the first time: I'm not defending the invasion of Iraq. So you can stop saying "But Iraq!" as if that somehow refutes my position. It doesn't. (Neither does "But Afghanistan!")

> "Preparing" meaning brainwashing, correct?

Well, take Japan. The people there had been brainwashed into a cult of the emperor and militarism. So the choice is, leave them brainwashed into something that sees no problem with trying to kill massive numbers of foreigners, or brainwash them into something else.

Again, what gives us the right to choose to do so? That they attacked us, and that we won.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by mc32 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @02:57PM (#22452648)
Cut your losses. We should never had been in there other than to get OBL but Bush chickened out with AF and didn’t make them give him up when we knew where he went to after Tora Bora.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by basementcat on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:06PM (#22452701)
Alternatively it is an inspiring story of a bunch of ragtag rebels who never gave up and never lost faith for decades and ultimately defeated the World’s most powerful military.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by sytelus on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:43PM (#22453322)
This has been a recurring theme in history. If you want to overthrow the world's largest best equipped most powerful armies, build a small guerilla force of ragtag rebels. This also applies to startups, research, engineering and other facets of life.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by sintaxi on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:03PM (#22452685)
Israel lost. U.S. had no business being there in the first place.