News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Galileo was right, but so were his critics (2015) by foldr on Friday February 28, 2020 @07:35AM (#22442333)
You're also cherry picking a bit. For example, Galielo failed to observe any parallax effect.

More broadly, it's a classic case of parsimony vs empirical coverage. Galileo's model did not enable better predictions, in the short term. Parsimony arguments are always more persuasive in retrospect, when we know that the theory in question is correct. There are many parsimonious but wrong theories. It was not unreasonable at the time to think that Galielo's theory might have been one of them.

>then apply modern arguments not known to people at the time (the actual size of stars) to say that Galileo's scientific argument was weak

I think you're misreading the argument. They point out that Galileo's theory appeared to require all other stars to be much bigger than the Sun, which seemed implausible at the time. This point was made by Galileo's contemporaries, so it can't be anachronistic.

Re:Galileo was right, but so were his critics (2015) by DiogenesKynikos on Friday February 28, 2020 @03:00PM (#22445804)
> Galielo failed to observe any parallax effect.

That's the same issue - the size argument. Without the argument about the sizes of stars, not observing parallax is not a problem at all. One can simply say that stars are far away.

> Galileo's model did not enable better predictions, in the short term.

Galileo did not have a model. He advocated Copernicus' heliocentric model, though I think his general attachment was more to heliocentrism than any particular heliocentric model (he appears not to have been particularly aware of Kepler's model).

> They point out that Galileo's theory appeared to require all other stars to be much bigger than the Sun, which seemed implausible at the time. This point was made by Galileo's contemporaries, so it can't be anachronistic.

Galileo measured much smaller stellar angular diameters than Tycho had, which very much called into question the reliability of the measurements. Arguing, based on modern knowledge, that stars are not so large, and insisting that this is the decisive argument, does come across as anachronistic to me. At the time, there were many other arguments in favor of heliocentrism that were very quickly accepted by a large part of the scientific community (particularly in Protestant Europe, beyond the control of the Church). Heliocentrism was widely accepted long before the star size objection was definitively answered (by an understanding of diffraction), and hundreds of years before the measurement of parallax. It was widely accepted even before a proper theory of gravity had been developed.

Re:Galileo was right, but so were his critics (2015) by foldr on Saturday February 29, 2020 @06:33AM (#22450103)
Galileo's arguments were reasonable and we know with hindsight that he was right. But that doesn't mean that all of the resistance of his ideas was unreasonable.

The star size objection clearly isn't anachronistic because it was considered to be a serious objection by other scientists at the time, on purely scientific grounds.

Re:Galileo was right, but so were his critics (2015) by DiogenesKynikos on Saturday February 29, 2020 @10:37AM (#22451052)
> it was considered to be a serious objection by other scientists at the time, on purely scientific grounds.

Not by most scientists, who adopted heliocentrism long before diffraction was understood.

And again, the opposition from the Church was due to theological and political reasons.

Re:Galileo was right, but so were his critics (2015) by foldr on Monday March 02, 2020 @04:59AM (#22463067)
>Not by most scientists

What's your source for the "most" here? Certainly there were prominent contemporaries of Galileo who took the star size objection seriously.

>And again, the opposition from the Church was due to theological and political reasons.

Partly. The Church didn't want to make theological revisions in the absence of a compelling scientific case for heliocentrism. So the scientific status of the claims was important as well.

Re:Galileo was right, but so were his critics (2015) by DiogenesKynikos on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @04:28AM (#22473059)
> What's your source for the "most" here?

Most of the major scientific minds beyond the control of the Inquisition (i.e., in Protestant Europe). Heliocentrism was widely accepted by the time of Galileo's death, even though diffraction had not yet been understood (meaning that the star-size objection was still unanswered). It's significant that the next generation of scientists - Hooke, Newton et al. - were committed to the New Science, rather than the old geocentric worldview.

> So the scientific status of the claims was important as well.

The scientific status of the claims was irrelevant to the Church. The idea that it was is pure modern apologia. From the context of the times (the Counter-Reformation) and the texts of the Inquisition's decisions (which emphasize the heretical nature of heliocentrism), it's clear that what the Church cared about was enforcing its control over doctrine. This was an era in which the Church was in a bitter battle against heresy, trying to fight the spread of Protestantism and reassert control.

Re:Galileo was right, but so were his critics (2015) by foldr on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @05:48AM (#22482700)
It's not the case that most of the major scientific minds beyond the control of the Inquisition immediately accepted Galileo's work. In fact, he was not particularly influential in scientific circles, in the short term.

Of course the Church wanted to enforce its control over doctrine. But the Church was also fully aware that the Bible could potentially be interpreted in a way that was not contrary to heliocentrism. It simply wanted to avoid making a fairly significant doctrinal revision in the absence of a compelling scientific case for heliocentrism. That is not to say that such restrictions on scientific work are justified, merely that it's inaccurate to see the Church in this instance as acting from blind dogmatism.

Re:Galileo was right, but so were his critics (2015) by DiogenesKynikos on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:42PM (#22488465)
> But the Church was also fully aware that the Bible could potentially be interpreted in a way that was not contrary to heliocentrism.

The Inquisition's assessment of heliocentrism explicitly contradicts your claim:

> All said that this proposition is foolish and absurd in philosophy, and formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts many places the sense of Holy Scripture, according to the literal meaning of the words and according to the common interpretation and understanding of the Holy Fathers and the doctors of theology. - The Inquisition, 1616

Your claim that

> It simply wanted to avoid making a fairly significant doctrinal revision in the absence of a compelling scientific case for heliocentrism.

... is simply not supported at all by the Inquisition's own statements. The Inquisition was very clear that heliocentrism must be false, because it contradicted the literal meaning of Holy Scripture. The Inquisition didn't say that heliocentrism was an open question to consider. It positively declared that heliocentrism is false and that the Earth stands still, and it grounded that statement by pointing to a literal reading of Scripture.

> it's inaccurate to see the Church in this instance as acting from blind dogmatism

I don't see any possible way to interpret the Inquisition's judgment on heliocentrism as anything other than blind dogmatism. In modern apologia, the Inquisition's rulings are rarely cited, because they contradict the key points that modern apologists make (about the Church supposedly being interested in scientific caution, etc.). I get the sense that people are trying to defend the 17th Century Church from criticisms rooted in a modern sensibility (which accepts empiricism and rejects religious dogma), ignoring the fact that the 17th Century Church (and most people in Western Christendom at the time) did not share our modern sensibilities.