"The most devastating argument against the Copernican universe was the star size problem. When we look at a star in the sky, it appears to have a small, fixed width. Knowing this width and the distance to the star, simple geometry reveals how big the star is (right). In geocentric models of the universe, the stars lie just beyond the planets, implying that star sizes are comparable to that of the sun (below). But Copernicus's heliocentric theory demands that the stars be extremely far away. This in turn implies that they should be absurdly large—hundreds of times bigger than the sun (bottom). Copernicans could not explain away the anomalous data without appeals to divine intervention. In reality, the stars are far away, but their apparent width is an illusion, an artifact of the way light behaves as it enters a pupil or telescope—behavior that scientists would not understand for another 200 years."
Also let's see, so a typical telescope aperture of the era have been 25-30mm (bigger will make focal ratio too big and chromatism totally unacceptable), which means Airy disk 5" big, or 1/40000 of the distance. Assuming stars being 1/15 parsec away to make their parallax just barely unobservable, it means yeah, stars 25x the size of Sun, which is whole lot and isn't a reasonable assumption.
But measuring Airy disk size is easy by using a hair put in the focal plane to see how quickly it crosses (will be 1/2 vs 1/4 of a second)... Easy experiment to check that Airy disk isn't a "star".
- Procyon has the same diameter and brightness as Saturn.
- If Procyon is much farther than (say) 100 times Saturn’s distance, simple geometry proves its actual size would dwarf the sun.
- All the stars would dwarf the Sun, which would then be the only pea in a universe of melons, which is absurd.
- But if Procyon were any closer, there would be visible parallax from the Earth's revolution.
- There is no visible parallax.
- Lack of parallax plus the apparent size of the stars therefore requires a stationary Earth. QED.
The problem with heliocentrism is that it requires a lot of additional hypothesis that are not needed by other (better performing !) models.
1. Why do some planets undergo retrograde motion, while others don't?
2. Why does retrograde motion only occur when a planet is opposite the Sun?
3. Why is there retrograde motion at all?
4. Why is it that we always observe smaller objects orbiting larger objects? (the Moon orbits the Earth, Jupiter's moons orbit Jupiter, implying that the Earth probably also orbits the Sun)
5. What are the orbital distances of the planets? This is completely undermined in the geocentric system, but very tightly constrained in the heliocentric system! In a geocentric world, there's no reason why it should be possible to even create a reasonably fitting heliocentric model. The opposite is not true.
Different oservations of apparent angular diameters were wildly inconsistent at the time of Galileo. It's natural that he would give less credence to an argument based on such shaky observations, and more credence to the many types of observations that favored heliocentrism.
Beyond these observations, there was a more general consideration. The geocentric model had been based on a view of the Universe that held the Earth to be fundamentally different from the heavens. Galileo's observations (of mountains and craters on the Moon and of sunspots, for example) showed that the heavens were actually very much like the Earth. The heavens were not a separate realm of perfect forms. They were made up of real worlds with their own landscapes and imperfections. Putting the Earth at the center of that Universe seemed absurd, whereas it hadn't before.
How could he possibly that have determined? I don't think that Brahe could measure this he hadn't even a telescope. The apparent diameter you see from stars is diffraction limited.
> Graney suggested in 2008 that Galileo's observations of stars were actually diffraction patterns called Airy disks
[1] https://www.nature.com/news/2010/100305/full/news.2010.105.h...
[2] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00016-007-0345-3
Yes there was lack of observable star parallax. But XVII measurement precision was so, so much worse than the one required to detect parallax (15" was best precision achieved at the time vs <1" required to tentatively detect parallax and ~0.3" required to be sure about it), that stars could "be" 50x closer than they really are, and 50x smaller, and the world would still "fit" the observations if one assumes that parallax is just tad small enough to escape detection. Which means, nearly every star being much smaller than Sun. Such a small star is impossible, but since source of the stellar energy wasn't known anyway, that couldn't be determined.