Re:Interview with Richard Stallman
by bandushrew on Sunday February 20, 2011 @10:04PM
(#2244077)
The GPL clearly does provide restrictions on the use of software released under it.
'people like myself who believe that freedom is an utmost concern'
which freedoms matter to you, and for whom? without context your statement is pretty much content free.
IME almost everyone believes that freedom is an utmost concern, even Brutalog, the Despotic Dictator Of Zoogtzargle believed that he was fighting the good fight for freedom.
The interesting differences seem to lie in the context under which they define the term.
Still, I find the GPL to be more restrictive and less free than the public domain, and therefore less desirable. I take issue with the way RMS and GNU uses the words "free" and "freedom" because I see their philosophy not as a principled desire for freedom, but rather merely as a desire for certain restrictions on freedom (granted, a different set of restrictions than proprietary software licenses).
I think that "The Free Software Movement" is an unfortunate title. Not only do they have to constantly remind average readers of their definition of "free as in speech, not as in beer," they also should be clarifying their definition of "free" for people like myself who believe that freedom is an utmost concern. Perhaps a better though less catchy title for their movements would be "The Publicly Available Source Code Movement."