Ask HN: Will there be any Facebook killer in the near future?
A friend of mine approached me with a nice social idea. I am technical person, I liked the idea and I genuinely believe it can be disruptive (but that just me). But then looking on the growth of Facebook and their armors I am bit skeptical about our ability to execute something this big especially when we have no history of execution. When we talked with others, we sounded so naive in fact a laughing matter. Coming back to main question,
Will there be any Facebook killer/rival in the near future? (Assuming someone else in a MIT dorm or in a remote African safari is trying to come up with that).
If yes, How much important you think time of entry will be if they have to succeed? Do you think hype surrounding Facebook can kill some potential entrants due to poor adaptation?
As for as my tiny world is considered, I think no one actually seriously tried to challenge the Facebook not even Google or Twitter. Same goes for Google. Problem of scale is so big that it is near impossible to take on Google or Facebook.
(
12 comments
| 16 points
| on HN
)
A Facebook killer won't come in the form of something similar to Facebook, it'll come in the form of something more time consuming and easier to waste time on than Facebook. It'll be something that lets people do something that they enjoy, and do it every hour or so with a different result. (here, i'm referencing what I think most people do in FB, and that's just browse people's pictures) It won't kill Facebook by being a better Facebook, it'll kill it by attracting people's attention elsewhere.
And I guess the whole 'scaling' aspect can be quite 'scary' when you look at sites with millions of members such as Facebook but I'd say screw that for now and just get started, by the time you really need to expand your infrastructure, things (such as your team, capital and so on) will be different anyhow. In order to avoid any downvotes: of course, keep scaling in mind. But put the main focus on your ideas and the overall experience.
And regarding the demise of Facebook in general: hopefully. I really dislike the corporateness and general lack of 'coolness' on Facebook. Myspace felt a lot better and was tons more fun to me than Facebook, all technical and visual shortcomings aside.
I can't imagine anyone 'feeling at home' on Facebook.
While they may not kill Facebook or even amass half as many members in the next two years, I would definitely say that I can see Tumblr and Lockerz experiencing explosive growth over the next 12-18 months. This growth is significant because it is all targeted at the 13-25 crowd - one of the most lucrative and influential demographics.
So, Facebook is huge and still growing (albeit mostly in the 35+ age group) but the young crowd is spending time in places where they can consume (media, interaction, discovery) all in one place rather than broadcast (status updates, chats, messages).
Sorry to say this, but you're considered the old person for the tumblr user base. Alot. Alot of 12-17 yr olds are on it. If you're in junior high, or high school all your friends are on it. And they will pull ppl in, like facebook did.
facebook has become the new email. And just as stale.
Tumblr? Not a definite need there.