Re:DOJ plans to strike against encryption while the Techlash...
by u801e on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @01:38PM
(#22425824)
Then again, given speeding is so widely accepted, radar detectors are legal to use in 49 out of 50 states. It would be nice if encryption was viewed the same way.
Re:DOJ plans to strike against encryption while the Techlash...
by JoshTriplett on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @02:55PM
(#22426647)
No, we absolutely don't want strong encryption viewed as "illegal but accepted", we want it viewed as "absolute necessity for day-to-day life and personal safety, unacceptable to ever weaken".
Re:DOJ plans to strike against encryption while the Techlash...
by u801e on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @03:00PM
(#22426708)
I think it comes down to popular vote versus government policy. While things like speeding and marijuana are illegal, popular votes have made these things legal (or quasi legal) in their respective jurisdictions. For example, votes to remove speed cameras or make them illegal, or votes to decriminalize marijuana.
But you are correct in that we really should make it completely legal so that the government doesn't have an excuse to target individuals for engaging in a practice that is generally widely accepted.
Re:DOJ plans to strike against encryption while the Techlash...
by blattimwind on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @01:51PM
(#22425932)
Isn't (relatively) strong encryption legal in every one of your 50 states and deployed to more than 10^10 devices globally?
People don't think 'encryption' is a mathematical function. They think it's like a radar detector in your car. "Why would you have it unless you intend on speeding?" [goes their thought process]
"Oh I use this frequently and things I do every day would be totally broken without it? Really?!" [is the realization we hope dialogue could bring]