Sort of agreed with this.
Based on my experience, the reality is a bit more complicated. As soon as one is past the "this VM is a special pet and it is the only one I have" stage in my experience even smaller companies get dozens and soon hundreds of distinct HTTPs entry points:
* Main site/API ( code )
* Ops support
* bizops ( invoicing/quoting )
Which is where the issues of monitoring and observability come up.
I bet techcrunch has close to a hundred HTTP/HTTPS entry points and every time they evaluate a solution to replace their current entry point structure they ask if the new method would at least solve all of their existing problems. Ops people aren't gong to add another partial solution so the mix.
I wouldn't be so sure about that. It's certainly possible that's the case but equally I've personally seen new sites on Techcrunch's scale literally served from a couple of a couple of boxes running Wordpress (I kid you not!) which sits behind a few more boxes running pretty aggressive Varnish profiles and then that is sat behind Akamai's CDN. Most of the content on news sites is static and highly cache-able so there isn't always the need to go down the micro-services route.
For example, does it run RabbitMQ anywhere? Rabbitmq admin front-end is HTTP. Same goes for Kafka and other applications and we aren't even touching bizops.
My point isn't to say you're wrong, just that there will be as many exceptions to your point as there are occasions it's accurate.
Can you elaborate on this? I'm not sure I follow; there's nothing preventing people from using something like https://ohdear.app/ (or any other monitoring tool) with a self-contained solution like Caddy. In fact, I recommend that people do.
This isn't how I like it, but I totally see the use case. Caddy is a part of that use case and is probably the reason it exists. I think that's fine!
(Edit: ohdear is really neat though, I think people might want that no matter what. You have to serve your status page from somewhere, might as well get some cert checks thrown in for free!)
The next problem that people will run into is that because they can't reliably run multiple "things", they won't have a monitoring stack to tell them that certs aren't renewing. But, maybe nothing bad will happen and it won't be a problem. "Hope is not a strategy" if you're a Google SRE, but people do pretty OK with hope in the real world ;)