News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by bluGill on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:42PM (#22417209)
Quoting generally limits you to 10-20% of the entire work quoted, and you must add a lot of detail to justify those quotes. You could maybe get around it by writing 100 books each that quote 1%.

Even then you might get into trouble if it can be shown your quotes are in order and thus you didn't apply any creative effort in choosing it. (out of order with page references so it can be assembled might be fine).

All of the above with a ton of maybe. It all depends on factors that are not entirely settled and subject to change.

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by salawat on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @05:12PM (#22418039)
>All of the above with a ton of maybe. It all depends on factors that are not entirely settled and subject to change.

That's the part I object to frankly.

For a second I had a hope that there were actually guidelines that helped clarify it, but even with the 10%-20% rule, yet if one managed to write and publish an entire set of pages enumerating every semantically correct page, we'd again be in the same problem.

As the process of creation becomes more available to the everyman, I can see that copyright is going to be a thornier and thornier issue. Especially if smaller and smaller chunks are going to be deemed as an acceptable basis for infringement without taking into account that the commonality of those smaller chunks being allegedly infringed upon must have the quality of being arranged in reference to every other part of the composition as a whole as well to count as an infringement of you're even attempting to achieve a reasonable outcome of copyright. Which means that you couldn't claim infringement merely for the presence of a work in another, which I'm fairly certain copyright holders would find unsatisfying because it would sharply curtail the value proposition represented by going after people for purportedly "infringing" in hopes of garnering a settlement, which is what it seems has become the norm rather than the exception in IP circles nowadays.