Re:Mozilla’s DNS over HTTPs
by the8472 on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:24PM
(#22417052)
> Even so, I don't even think such an API should exist.
There is no "exfiltrate all my history" in the webextension APIs. What exists are two distinct and reasonable components.
A) accessing browsing history/current tabs/network requests¹. all things required for extensions to work
B) ability to make generic network requets
Combining these two can be used to exfiltrate data. But that does not mean that any particular extension that has access to both will also exfiltrate private data. Thus a blanket warning would be overly broad and anything more targeted would require manual sourcecode inspection.
¹ Those require separate permissions, but for the purpose of the discussion they can all be used to harvest data
There is no "exfiltrate all my history" in the webextension APIs. What exists are two distinct and reasonable components.
A) accessing browsing history/current tabs/network requests¹. all things required for extensions to work B) ability to make generic network requets
Combining these two can be used to exfiltrate data. But that does not mean that any particular extension that has access to both will also exfiltrate private data. Thus a blanket warning would be overly broad and anything more targeted would require manual sourcecode inspection.
¹ Those require separate permissions, but for the purpose of the discussion they can all be used to harvest data