Re:Mozilla’s DNS over HTTPs
by JohnFen on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:23PM
(#22417036)
> More prevalent end-to-end encryption is a good thing.
I agree -- I am not arguing against more prevalent e2e crypto at all.
> If an encrypted DNS scheme is blockable by you, it's blockable by an ISP.
Perhaps, but it's also possible (unless you're using DoH) to evade those blocks without a great deal of difficulty.
I'm not arguing with anything you've said here, really. I'm just pointing out that the way that DoH works means that there is a security hole that makes it very easy for marketers and other spies to evade your protections against them.
So yes, DoH brings some security gains. But at the same time, it also brings some security losses. Whether that tradeoff is good for you should be a decision you can make -- but again, due to the way DoH works, you no longer have that choice available to you without going to extreme measures like I have.
I agree -- I am not arguing against more prevalent e2e crypto at all.
> If an encrypted DNS scheme is blockable by you, it's blockable by an ISP.
Perhaps, but it's also possible (unless you're using DoH) to evade those blocks without a great deal of difficulty.
I'm not arguing with anything you've said here, really. I'm just pointing out that the way that DoH works means that there is a security hole that makes it very easy for marketers and other spies to evade your protections against them.
So yes, DoH brings some security gains. But at the same time, it also brings some security losses. Whether that tradeoff is good for you should be a decision you can make -- but again, due to the way DoH works, you no longer have that choice available to you without going to extreme measures like I have.