Unfortunately, the US government is one of the larger users of ISP surveillance activities, benefiting through the purchase of private data as well as using administrative subpoena to obtain the data collected by ISPs without due process or meaningful oversight.
This creates a conflict of interest which I believe is preventing the US from zealously enforcing existing criminal law which would be otherwise sufficient to significantly reduce surveillance by communications providers.
Firefox should not be forcing this shit on me, time to search for yet another browser that will respect users. Mozilla is clearly more interested in commercial viability via their partnerships with large corporations (like CloudFlare) then in protecting Users
* Using DoH. For this to work with PiHole, you need to have a DoH resolver on the device, and then instruct the PiHole to recurse to that resolver instead - possibly your own in a VM somewhere?
* Using a permanent encrypted VPN to your own machine in the cloud and routing all DNS through that, then recursing to some DNS that you trust.
* Write your own encrypted protocol that communicates with some machine in the cloud.
Anything else and your ISP/evil-state-actor is able to to see your DNS traffic in plain-text. PiHole and DoH approach the problem at different OSI layers, you ideally need both.
and you believe CloudFlare is not a "evil state actor" or has not been compromised or never will be compromised by an "evil state actor"
Wow your faith in CloudFlare is much much higher than mine
Personally I trust my current ISP (which is not one of the big boys) more than I trust CloudFlare.
I do not trust cloudflare at all and believe they are the are one of the biggest threats to the future of open web there is today.
For example, because it’s not using HTTP, there are no cookies or SNI to worry about.
> For example, because it’s not using HTTP, there are no cookies or SNI to worry about.
> More at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22418005.
The fact that it can be trivially blocked by anyone on the network path does not make it "much better".
Of course anyone on the "network path" can block almost any protocol; DoT isn’t unique in that regard.
The concern is many large businesses block port 853 but that's because prior to the development of DoT, there was no reason for IT departments to configure firewalls to enable it. Most organizations only have a handful of ports available, including 443, which is what HTTPS uses and therefore DoH works as a result.
I've been running DNS over TLS using the Unbound [1] resolver for my home LAN on a spare laptop for a few weeks now and it’s been great.
Given the privacy trade-offs between privacy and security, many IT departments would opt to make port 853 available for DoT rather than increasing the ability for their users to be tracked.
As I mentioned elsewhere in this thread, the article Centralised DoH is bad for Privacy, in 2019 and beyond [2] clearly describes the issues with DoH:
DNS over HTTPS opens up DNS to all the tracking possibilities present in HTTPS and TLS. As it stands, DNS over UDP almost always gets some free privacy by mixing all devices on a network together – an outside snooper sees a stream of queries coming from a household, a coffeeshop or even an entire office building, with no way to tie a query to any specific device or user. Such mixing of queries provides an imperfect but useful modicum of privacy.
DNS over HTTPS however neatly separates out each device (and even each individual application on that device) to a separate query stream. This alone is worrying, as we now have individual users’ queries, but the TLS that underlies HTTPS also typically uses TLS Resumption which offers even further tracking capabilities.
[1]: https://www.ctrl.blog/entry/unbound-tls-forwarding.html
[2]: https://labs.ripe.net/Members/bert_hubert/centralised-doh-is...
Sure, but until we have encrypted SNI, which is in draft, meta data is going to leak, but that's a separate issue from either DoT or DoH.
But because DoT doesn't use HTTPS, you don't get some of its downsides like using cookies for tracking, for example.
DoH shares the benefits and downsides of HTTPS. It sends out more trackable data than regular DNS, simply because HTTP supports things like headers and cookies. TLS session resumption functions as another tracking mechanism.
There’s a draft RFC [2] to address these and other privacy issues that weren't specified in the original RFC for DoH.
[1]: https://labs.ripe.net/Members/bert_hubert/the-big-dns-privac...
[2]: https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-dickinson-doh-dohpe-00...
They've built up a considerable amount of good-will in developer communities. Is there some historical indicator with cloudfare that suggests they are going to blow it all on their path to monetization, or are we extrapolating from other VC backed companies (which may be an understandable position to take, but why?)
Cloudflare isn’t really known as a privacy champion, they always put more emphasis on security, speed and reliability.
From a privacy perspective it’s pretty horrible what they do as well, because they decrypt and inspect all traffic between their customers and those customers users. Security-wise it might be great, but don’t confuse security with privacy.
I really hope that I’m wrong but I’m skeptical that Cloudflare will turn down such a big opportunity, and this move with DoH really seems to confirm this.
There are many things that could be done. The problem is that the promises they make sound grand but aren't real, they wouldn't put the value of their homes at risk (nor would I encourage them to, I'd encourage them to not put themselves in a position where they could be forced to compromise the privacy of the public like this) ---- yet some user's lives can be put at risk by privacy-failures of their service.
So the question is "What happens when CloudFlare violates the contract" do they get a strongly worded email from Mozilla?
bad PR?
Or is it s bankruptcy causing event for the company. Anything besides that means the contract is worthless
In my world, everyone has a story about how an obscure but interesting to surveil service that they were involved with was DDOS attacked and immediately cloudflare sales was showing up offering to mitigate the attack for free by MITMing their traffic. ... Even showing up on the IRC channels of open source projects. I've personally witnessed it three times.
Even if it weren't for the fact that it would be gross incompetence if the NSA hadn't compromised cloudflare up, down, and sidewise since it's such an attractive target, the surveillance based sales-leads approach used by cloudflare has convinced a lot of people that they're engaging in a protection racket. Not just technies, either-- I've heard from executives who pay for cloudflare service that they think is a protection racket but they pay anyways because it's just a cost of doing business.
[I don't personally think it is, but I think that cloudflare is unethically creating a situation where some customers will believe this and pay as a result.]
It's such a lovely setup for a state attacker. Step 1. Compromise cloudflare (either by getting insiders into it, or by hacking them). Step 2. DDOS attack the thing you really want to monitor. Step 3. Cloudflare sales shows up and helps onboard the victim onto your borrowed surveillance platform.
People think that kind of stuff about AV companies, but at least AV companies aren't showing up within minutes of an attack saying "Gee, isn't it so terrible that you've got a virus. We've got a cure for that!". At least AV companies mostly don't send your data all back to their servers where god knows what happens to it.
Even where the problem is usually just a volumetric DDOS, the cloudflare standard solution is a full encryption unwrapping layer-7 MITM.
DoH without cloudflare would also gather complaint but the fact that the default centralized panoptiresolver is cloudflare contributes a lot to many people's discomfort.
So, I don't think cloudflare has amassed much goodwill at all, and that's even before getting into how their 'protection' made much of the internet unusable behind tor or other anonymization proxies.
Funnily enough Cloudflare supports DNS over Tor[1][2], and I think they are the only one. Please let me know if there are others!
[1] https://developers.cloudflare.com/1.1.1.1/fun-stuff/dns-over...
You profess not to believe these theories, or at least not the first one. So why then repeat? It's just more untruths poisoning this debate, like any other going on these days.
And how does Cloudflare get the blame in your telling of this story, when it's your unnamed sources "you've heard" believing paranoid stories? DDOS were a thing before Cloudflare, and the incident numbers haven't much changed. So if it's Cloudflare doing it all now, they must have simultaneously convinced everyone else to stop.
The idea that their salespeople showing up when you're under attack is similarly strange: While I might agree that it feels somewhat creepy, is there any doubt that these things are easy to notice with some saved twitter searches and a google alert? It also strikes me as a potentially quite useful sales tactic. And yet, even though it's feasible and effective, they are supposed to forgo that channel to stop others from engaging in obviously flawed reasoning?
You must not get out much. :)
> things are easy to notice with some saved twitter searches and a google alert?
They are not doing this through twitter searches or google alerts. They show up when there is absolutely no mention of it anywhere, even sometimes when the attack is largely ineffective. Expectations like yours-- that they could only discover them from public sources-- probably contributes to people believing the attacks originate from cloudflare.
They use sampled netflow data from ISP to detect large scale DDOS attacks (presumably buying the information from arbor networks or similar, where they don't have their own coverage).
Cloudflare is now a public company and they need to aggressively monetize their services. Selling browsing data is a lucrative business and becoming “the” DNS provider for most users (while locking out all other players) is a great way to build a data monopoly.
Not to mention that being the number one DNS provider will give them many opportunities to break domain resolution for users that don’t use their DoH service, as they also control the DNS entries for many sites (they could e.g. make propagation via normal DNS slower or start providing only a limited set of entries over “insecure” DNS).