On the other side, I think it's a very different problem, and I'd advise to not mix things up: there's style, there's identity, there are UI canons.
Bultwithme for example mixes web+mac UI canons, has a mac style and doesn't work a lot on identity.
Take Nike.com to have another example. It uses a web style, a bit toward the app format, with UI canons that are almost everywhere app-like... but it has a very strong identity.
On the other side, take Lightroom. It's obviously an app and uses desktop UI canon... but it has a definite identity that you can't mix up with anything else.
Also dropbox, as you cited, uses a quite standard web style and web UI canon, but it has a strong identity.
Don't reduce the identity to the UI canons or interaction styles: they are very different things. ;)
I also think that some of this design habits also point in the wrong direction. Just to explain better, I'd say that Drew Wilson is iconic of this. He's quite popular, and you can see some of his work here: http://dribbble.com/drewwilson/ He uses a mac-like style for web applications, and I think this is a huge mistake. Try to visit http://builditwith.me/: it's surely beautiful, but do you think it's 'usable'? I think it's not. But the most, I think it has no distinctiveness. Here there's another mistake: distinctiveness does not mean originality. My examples where websites like mint.com or posterous, or even Dropbox. These website can't be called that original, but they surely have a distinctive design, made of key and recognizable colors, way to use (or not) gradients, etc.
In my humble opinion, any design must obviously respect some key principles, like effectiveness or usability. But I also think that any design should point on 'identity', especially when building a web app, something most designers don't seem to care about.