http://techrights.org/2009/07/09/community-promise-sham/
and
http://www.fsf.org/news/2009-07-mscp-mono
and of Mono in general:
Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @migueldeicaza (http://twitter.com/#!/migueldeicaza)
That's where I stopped reading, but I'll say this: Nowhere in the FSF's critique of the MCP is it mentioned whether or not the promise itself is legally binding. From a bunch of people who are supposed to be legal experts. What does that tell you?
But, as far as that particular issue is concerned, as the techrights article points out,
"It may become legally binding ... if used as a challenge in court. But of course it does actually need to be tested in court /first/."
In any case, you might want to look up the legal term estoppel.
So please stop repeating estoppel meme, it is nonsense. Also, attacking all people who show the world truth about Mono shows you have no arguments. Reddit was spammed by Mono pushers who were impersonating other people.
In any case, sorry, but I'm not going to argue this issue with the likes of you. You may have a point somewhere, perhaps, but anyone associated with that blog has about as much credibility vis-a-vis Mono as Rush Limbaugh does when he talks about... well, anything. I bid you adieu sir. Good luck.
I don't know who "gnosis" is, first saw that nick.
Anyways, if you need to attack people and make this kind of nonsense, it means you have no arguments whatsoever, so you just do what rabid Mono pushers always do: character assassination and libeling of every critic, with heavy use of all kind of fallacies.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem
C ya
Citing Boycott Novell about software (or about anything, actually) is about equivalent of citing your Astrologer in a science argument.
Why don't you actually address what they wrote in their article?
An ad Hominem attack would be calling you stupid for linking the biased source. That didn't happen.
I didn't even make an argument. I just linked to a few articles that criticized Microsoft's "Promise".
Did tsz address the substance of techrights' argument? No. He just smeared them by implying that merely citing an article by them would make me lose credibility.
That is a perfect example of an ad hominem.
Attacking me was more of a case of shooting the messenger.
If you do a Google site search on that blog you'll see that the term 'smear' is used endlessly and quite carelessly by the author. It's interesting to see that you use it in the same way - and like the author I don't think you understand very well what the term means. I sure hope "gnosis" isn't one of the various aliases the guy allegedly uses across the internet, including on Slashdot where he became a bit of a legend for maintaining dozens of them.
But, be that as it may, I'll just say that yesterday was the first day I've even heard of techrights, when I found their site through a google search.
And, honestly, I don't even care much about Mono. I'm just very suspicious of anything originating from Microsoft, and the techrights and FSF articles support these (well founded) suspicions.
Instead of dancing in circles, please look at the contact information I posted above. Miguel de Icaza is a good guy. I am certain he will answer any questions you might have.
...The danger is that Microsoft is probably planning to force all free C# implementations underground some day using software patents. ... This is a serious danger, and only fools would ignore it...
It seems as if they are passing off wild speculation as inevitable fact. What is to prevent MS from using its portfolio of patents on any given project? Is a free C# implementation infringing on more patents? The supporting links just looked like general anti-patent pages.
* From the Mono Licensing FAQ [1]: "Microsoft has announced that the ECMA standards for C# and the CLI are covered under the Community Promise patent license. Basically a grant is given to anyone who want to implement those components for free and for any purpose."
* The Novell-Microsoft agreements provide further protection for companies that choose to use Mono. [1]
* Many companies are using Mono for commercial purposes. There is a list at http://www.mono-project.com/Companies_Using_Mono
* Notably, Linden Studios uses Mono for Second Life servers. (See http://wiki.secondlife.com/wiki/Mono)
[1] http://www.mono-project.com/Licensing#Patents