News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by dev_hacker on Monday February 24, 2020 @08:18AM (#22403724)
This article glosses over the fact, known to us who have witnessed humans up close in business environments, that success is almost entirely political within an organization.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by CarelessExpert on Monday February 24, 2020 @08:29AM (#22403787)
Not to mention one of the most important factors of all: luck.

But survivorship bias means we assume all successful people hold a unique skill and wisdom that, if we only did the same, we'd find similar success.

Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by sparker72678 on Monday February 24, 2020 @10:23AM (#22404746)
Yes. 100%.

I don't think anyone likes to admit that very few things in life are actually within our control, which makes it desirable to ascribe success to hard work, or intelligence, or whatever.

I started a consultancy that failed, was part of a small team with a moderately successful product, and now am part of a small team with a much more successful product.

All of that happened while former colleagues were working on much more successful products making a lot more money than I was.

In none of those cases was the outcome related to hard work, skill, or desire.

Sometimes you have the right people together in the right place at the right time. Sometimes you don't.

---

None of which is to say that luck is the _only_ factor. Part of taking advantage of the luck is doing the best work you can, and honing your skills to the best of your ability, so that if the opportunity pops up you can grab it.

But just because you haven't had the success you've wanted doesn't mean there's anything wrong with you at all.

Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by collyw on Monday February 24, 2020 @09:36AM (#22404245)
Would you agree that working hard will generate more opportunities to be lucky?
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by bdavisx on Monday February 24, 2020 @10:13AM (#22404640)
I would agree that having wealthy parents generates a lot more opportunities to be lucky.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by CarelessExpert on Monday February 24, 2020 @01:32PM (#22406861)
Which is itself just another form of luck.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by collyw on Monday February 24, 2020 @11:59AM (#22405803)
I'll take that as a yes.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by EliRivers on Monday February 24, 2020 @01:32PM (#22406856)
Indeed, we all interpret in favour of our preconceptions.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by collyw on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:15AM (#22411619)
Refusing to answer the question implies that he didn't want to admit that my suggestion was correct.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by schwurb on Monday February 24, 2020 @09:49AM (#22404381)
So does buying more lottery tickets. Surely, the odds at being lucky are better than in playing lottery. However, they are much less predictable than people assume. We tend to systematically overestimate our own influence and underestimate external factors.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by kgantchev on Monday February 24, 2020 @09:56AM (#22404443)
Then why do we value talented people at all? How much of their work is luck and how much is talent? If not much is talent, then I should be able to get lucky with people who aren't talented.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by AstralStorm on Monday February 24, 2020 @11:45AM (#22405644)
There are degrees of success. Doing good work is only the most basic. Even really good work you're talented in.

Getting anything else requires opportunity. Even discovering where your talents lie takes resources.

And there's also genetic luck, not necessarily biological but also wealth and environment. Without that many talents are unknown or undeveloped. This kind of luck cannot be made.

Nobody can actually find people with undeveloped talents. You'd have to force them to try a wide variety of occupations, preferably early so that they can develop it.

The people we value are not just any talented, they're developed talents that have been noticed, and beyond that lucky geniuses.

Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by BerislavLopac on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @07:21PM (#22419046)
No. Or rather yes, but it also generates equally more opportunity to be unlucky. So the two cancel out.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by redisman on Monday February 24, 2020 @02:21PM (#22407401)
But hold on, why don't you just buy this cargo-cult self-help book and you too can be a success*!
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by kryptiskt on Monday February 24, 2020 @09:31AM (#22404203)
One would think that being smart should be an asset when playing politics, though.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by dougmwne on Monday February 24, 2020 @10:13AM (#22404645)
I think you really illustrate GP's point in a fantastic way. Let's define "smart" as the kind of smarts that would be in abundance on HN: Technical smarts, rapid learning smarts, knowledge smarts, creative smarts, idea smarts.

A smart person might be good at school and individual contribuitorship, and so believe that they should naturally be good at political games as well. But truly, politics takes a whole other set of smarts and the things that make you an excellent IC do not much overlap with things that make you good at the political game: charisma, selling, risk-taking, deep emotional intelligence, extroversion, strategic intuition, sociopathy, commanding presence.

Many smart engineers can't even see see that the game is being played or they realize it long after the match has been won. They are not the players, but the pieces on the board.

Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by dev_hacker on Monday February 24, 2020 @02:22PM (#22407404)
This is so true and sad. Often the smartest people at a company are literally just being moved about by the business people. They literally can't see the real game above them.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by Data_Junkie on Monday February 24, 2020 @04:08PM (#22408468)
That's because they are smart enough to know better. It is dumb people who play games with the lives of others, it is the fool who loves power.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by dougmwne on Monday February 24, 2020 @05:59PM (#22409354)
Typically not in my experience. Smart technical folks are subjected to plenty of suffering at the hands of leadership. The ones "smart enough to know better" find a way to insulate their livelihoods from capricious decision makers by either learning how to play the game or finding a way not to play (consulting or maybe creating their own product).

And I don't think it's accurate either to say that only fools love power. The need for power and status is deeply rooted in our evolution and psyche. To go back to Aristotle, man is the political animal.

Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by Data_Junkie on Monday February 24, 2020 @10:16PM (#22410633)
Very accurate to say the love of power makes a fool. A fool is just closer to an animal than a "wise" man. Power over another is just selfish, as love, or the care of more than yourself is altruistic. By smart enough to know better I meant they aren't the ones perpetuating the games, not that they are not suffering from the games. You flipped it backwards.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by rasz on Monday February 24, 2020 @10:20AM (#22404720)
Politics require social skills, being smart is detrimental because it lets you see thru all the bullshit.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by lotsofpulp on Monday February 24, 2020 @11:49AM (#22405689)
People who succeed at politics are able to do so because they can see through the bullshit, but also because they can pretend it’s not bullshit. Politics is war without the violence. You need you be able to signal to potential allies what you’re willing to give and take with plausible deniability.

Many smart, principled people aren’t able to sufficiently lie to themselves or feel comfortable using ambiguous terms and/or outright lying, and that hampers their ability to covertly send and receive signals to others, so others who are successful at politics would do well to stay away from them. You have to compromise in order to get things done, but it doesn’t behoove you to lay out all of your cards for everyone to see.

Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by Data_Junkie on Monday February 24, 2020 @03:00PM (#22407823)
The Elephant in the room. When it's all politics, as it is in most of modern society, success really has much more to do with the ability to lie and deceive than most are comfortable admitting. There in lies the entire problem, and the solution is inchomphesible to polititions who owe their entire self worth to their abilities to decieve.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by unlinked_dll on Monday February 24, 2020 @11:12AM (#22405320)
If you see the bullshit but don't deal with it, that doesn't make you smart. It makes you very, very stupid.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by AstralStorm on Monday February 24, 2020 @11:46AM (#22405660)
Dealing with politics in an advantageous way takes serious time and practice. You might be well behind the curve vs professionals.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by ikeyany on Monday February 24, 2020 @11:48AM (#22405683)
If you were smart, wouldn't you know how to optimally deal with bullshit?
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by heavenlyblue on Monday February 24, 2020 @01:36PM (#22406900)
This takes a whole different set of skills against e.g being good at programming.

For example, how do you react to inherently unfair situations, someone taking advantage of someone else? If you start picking on people good politicians will quickly “plausibility deniability” you out of the equation.

It’s much easier to accept (with a bit of anger) that you made a mistake in your program that bring defaced due to your “judgement being clouded by anger”.

You may be smart enough to even understand what you have to do, but it will take practice to do it well even if you understand it conceptually.

Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by ikeyany on Monday February 24, 2020 @03:12PM (#22407945)
Just because you're a good programmer doesn't mean you're smart.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by redisman on Monday February 24, 2020 @02:23PM (#22407417)
There are many different heuristics for what is "optimal". To many it is to be left alone to work on things they find interesting.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by rimliu on Monday February 24, 2020 @10:24AM (#22404749)
How is that detrimental in politics?
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by mamon on Monday February 24, 2020 @01:12PM (#22406603)
Smart, nerdy people tend to spend a lot of time alone with books/computers/hobbies, so they simply do not spend enough time with other people to properly develop their social skills.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by Data_Junkie on Monday February 24, 2020 @04:07PM (#22408451)
That is completely off track.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by mdgrech23 on Monday February 24, 2020 @09:54AM (#22404428)
Playing politics might be to abstract of a term. How about if someone in a position of power above you likes you or not. If say your bosses boss thinks your amazing then they can pull you up. Keep in mind though this big boss might only want to pull you up to undermine your current boss. that's the political part.
Re:Why smart hardworking people don't become successful (2018) by olau on Monday February 24, 2020 @09:53AM (#22404415)
Smart people I know tend to make their own decisions, including whether to participate in specific games or not.