Re:Ack - a faster, more featureful, grep
by neilc on Saturday June 21, 2008 @11:33PM
(#224024)
It seems like it is only faster because it applies a bunch of heuristics to avoid searching certain files and directories altogether. I use "ack" myself and it's quite nice, but the heuristics aren't perfect: ack won't search for strings inside yacc grammars (".y" files) by default, for example.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
True, part of the speed comes from it's (configurable) heuristics.
But, it's faster even when doing the same thing. For example, see the benchmark at http://blog.i-no.de/archives/2008/05/06/index.html.
Then end result is that, on the same search, ack is approximately 5 times faster than grep. I ran a few test cases myself and got similar results.
But the real reason I like it is the perl compatible regexes. The differences between perl regexes and gnu regexes are just big enough to be an annoyance.
In that particular case, ack's performance advantage seems to arise mostly because of a bug that causes GNU grep to be terribly slow in multibyte locales:
http://blog.i-no.de/archives/2008/05/07/index.html http://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/index.php?14472
It doesn't use "perl compatible regexes", it uses Perl.
I would argue that 'perl regexes' are a member of the set of 'perl compatible regexes' ;-)