Re:Why Open Source misses the point of Free Software
by brudgers on Saturday February 19, 2011 @05:32PM
(#2240114)
>"I prefer my software to remain open no matter who works on it or distributes it. So, I use GPL."
There are other licenses which will insure that your software remains free and open. GPL requires that mine become free and open as well...and that's fine in so far as it goes.
Structurally, however, the copyleft movement only works so long as there is a system of copyright protections, powerful institutions for enforcing them, and the threat of severe sanctions for violating them. In other words, the copyleft movement is built on the same foundation as its antithesis. Both copyright and copyleft depend on the author's right to restrict future use.
There are other licenses which will insure that your software remains free and open. GPL requires that mine become free and open as well...and that's fine in so far as it goes.
Structurally, however, the copyleft movement only works so long as there is a system of copyright protections, powerful institutions for enforcing them, and the threat of severe sanctions for violating them. In other words, the copyleft movement is built on the same foundation as its antithesis. Both copyright and copyleft depend on the author's right to restrict future use.