News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How important are 'economies of scale'? by WalterBright on Saturday February 22, 2020 @05:13PM (#22393686)
> To say that patents always stimulate innovation is obviously false to me.

Yeah, the historical record says it doesn't work. The same for copyrights. In the 1800s Germany had no copyright laws and their economy and innovation boomed. US industry was founded on ignoring British patents.

Today, look at innovation in open source software - without patents and copyrights, it proceeds at a breakneck pace.

Re:How important are 'economies of scale'? by snowwrestler on Saturday February 22, 2020 @05:24PM (#22393754)
Open source software depends on copyright to work.

Ignoring IP laws is a great way to catch up to stronger economies that are growing on innovation. Once you catch up, though, the only way to keep growing is to develop your own innovations... at which point you start caring more about IP laws. The U.S. went through this transition and China will too, pretty soon I think.

Re:How important are 'economies of scale'? by TaylorAlexander on Saturday February 22, 2020 @07:41PM (#22394339)
Your comment seems to ignore my assertion that there was more innovation in 3D printing after the patents expired, with much of that innovation being open source. That was not an example of catching up with someone else by copying them, it was an example of novel development done in the public interest.
Re:How important are 'economies of scale'? by abetusk on Saturday February 22, 2020 @05:34PM (#22393805)
That's like saying "antibiotics don't work without bacteria".

In my opinion, open source is so successful because the current copyright laws have overreached. My feeling is saner copyright duration would probably make open source all but disappear.