News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"It'll never work": a collection of failed predictions by necubi on Saturday February 19, 2011 @12:04PM (#2239346)
This statement is a clear and obvious logical fallacy, and should have appeared as such to contemporary audiences. He is saying that Animals have (limbs => they move) => (the Earth does not have limbs => it does not move). But the latter is the inverse of the former, which must be proven separately and which is not implied by the conditional.
Re:"It'll never work": a collection of failed predictions by davnola on Saturday February 19, 2011 @12:26PM (#2239390)
As I commented below, I expect the translation "move" makes it sound worse than it did in the original. If he means "are self-propelled" or "are mobile", it's slight less wrong.
Re:"It'll never work": a collection of failed predictions by apl on Saturday February 19, 2011 @12:32PM (#2239409)
That's correct.

Nonetheless, we can certainly grant him an implicit "Only living things (animals) can move (by themselves)." Doesn't make it any less wrong, but I doubt that it's just a logical fallacy.