News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Requirements volatility is the core problem of software e... by cameronbrown on Saturday February 22, 2020 @06:27AM (#22390470)
It can be in some circumstances..

I think that the engineering mindset (adherence to the scientific method, evidence based decisions, planning for the future etc..) is one that is definitely shared by both groups at least.

But you can absolutely get away with building software without proper engineering standards. It's not so easy to build bridges that way.

Re:Requirements volatility is the core problem of software e... by 1234_UUUU_99 on Saturday February 22, 2020 @07:41AM (#22390712)
> It's not so easy to build bridges that way.

I'd wager that it is but the stakes for failure are too high to wing it (hopefully).

Imagine:

We want to build a bridge that spans N meters. We don't know how to do it but we can go look at an existing bridge and copy it. We might not understand metallurgy / physics that well, but we talk to suppliers and ask for "steel of this shape and size". Ditto cables, concrete and everything else.

Probably, provided we're not scaling up or changing the design too much, it would work just fine.

Re:Requirements volatility is the core problem of software e... by radicalbyte on Saturday February 22, 2020 @08:06AM (#22390789)
You have cowboy builders in the "engineering" area too. For some reason in software we seem to be more accepting of it.
Re:Requirements volatility is the core problem of software e... by cameronbrown on Saturday February 22, 2020 @09:14AM (#22391122)
For most non-engineers (either kind), engineering is just a means to an end, i.e. don't care about the finer details as long as it works.

When software goes wrong, the effects are more often than not, intangible. When mechanical engineering or electrical engineering goes wrong, people can die.

Software can obviously kill people too, it just happens less. Then industry practices revert to the mean due to cost cutting.

Re:Requirements volatility is the core problem of software e... by klowner on Saturday February 22, 2020 @06:47AM (#22390537)
Too many companies taking a "McMansion" approach to software and we wonder why everything is constantly broken.