Re:Regulators probe Apple 30% subscription plan
by r00fus on Friday February 18, 2011 @02:17PM
(#2236801)
This platform-markup (30%) will affect other players because in order to show any of your content on iOS, you must not just mark up your price, but Apple demands price matching with other markets... that's the uncompetetive part, as that will just raise prices for everyone, unless all those subscription services and content providers ditch iOS en-masse (unlikely).
If Apple were to relinquish their price-match requirement (unlikely) or allow apps that had no external store references (more likely), they would not cause such an upheaval in pricing.
Re:Regulators probe Apple 30% subscription plan
by bradleyland on Friday February 18, 2011 @02:53PM
(#2236953)
I don't disagree. The question, I think, is whether or not regulatory agencies will force Apple to re-tool their terms. That will depend on whether or not Apple is found to have a dominant position in "the market". No one has defined "the market" yet though.
Hence, the standard rules of supply and demand apply. If you control 100% of the supply, you are a monopoly, so the question will become one of defining the supply. Is it iOS users? Is it mobile device owners? Is it media consumers? Where the definition falls on that continuum will define the outcome of the investigation.
I'd be very surprised if the regulatory agencies defined the supply as iOS users, so I think Apple will get away with this. Not that it matters much. I believe Apple has crossed the critical tipping point where sustainability exists only in niches, and will ultimately push away so many content distributors that the actual creators (those with the room to sell at a 30% markdown) won't be able to fill in the gaps fast enough. There will be volumes of content available on other platforms, and the attractiveness of iOS devices (and platform) will diminish. This will have the effect of accelerating competing platforms' growth lead. At that point, Apple will either react to the market, or relegate themselves to a small portion of the market that they will happily turn a huge profit on.