News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by akanet on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @11:57AM (#22367359)
Hi, I'm the author of the piece, perhaps better known here as founder of CoderPad. Feel free to ask me anything but things are a bit crazy right now!
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by intherdfield on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:56PM (#22368073)
I don't think you mentioned that the student doesn't have to pay back Lambda after 60 months of deferred payments. That seems important. From the Lambda site:

"The income share agreement has no interest. It's a flat percentage that goes away once you've reached the $30k payment cap, you've made 24 payments, or after 60 months of deferred payments (even if you haven't paid us anything)."

But you wrote in the article:

"Students with no safety nets experience real financial pain from the nine-month hiatus from work, in addition to the looming dread of possibly having to pay Lambda $30K one day."

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by x0x0 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @01:39PM (#22368558)
Still seems like a way better deal than student loans, which can follow you until you die.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by akanet on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @01:38PM (#22368556)
Yeah, got cut for brevity, but students definitely experience serious anxiety about even the five year horizon.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by the_watcher on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @02:17PM (#22368971)
It's a pretty important point though. Compare with a student loan, which never goes away. Failing to mention that seems in pretty clear bad faith.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by nemothekid on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @05:30PM (#22370806)
That seems like a giant omission. 5 years is nothing compared to student loans. There are people in their 40s still paying back loans they took when they were 18
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by intherdfield on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @02:49PM (#22369306)
That seems really disingenuous. Can't you update the article with this important detail?
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by akanet on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:17PM (#22371916)
It's not disingenuous; I think an earlier draft had it. This came down from 4000 words. I'll try to ask my editor to add this as a correction but things are pretty hectic. It's a fairly minor omission in my opinion, but I understand disagreeing.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by tomhoward on Thursday February 20, 2020 @12:10AM (#22372850)
It's hardly a "fairly minor omission" in a country where the conventional tertiary education saddles the average student with a debt that is often far bigger than $30k, doesn't expire, and cannot be escaped even through bankruptcy, meaning that even retirement benefits can be garnished above a meagre $750/month.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by 737min on Thursday February 20, 2020 @10:12AM (#22375572)
Agree it’s a minor point, can’t expect OP to fit every contractual detail in a short article.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by cambalache on Thursday February 20, 2020 @01:39PM (#22377417)
Well, it is to me.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by blackholesRhot on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:18PM (#22372190)
"Yeah, got cut for brevity, but students definitely experience serious anxiety about even the five year horizon."

Lambda School is <5 years old. Pretty disingenuous man.

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by hydrarijar on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @05:03PM (#22370585)
Writes a 2000+ word article, cuts 14 "for brevity".

Overall, I think this was an insightful article, but cutting that out seems misleading, even underhanded.

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by Step888 on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:26AM (#22381709)
And let's be honest here, I am no fan of Lambda school and I think it's way too expensive for an online school.

But if the editor cut those 14 words out, it wasn't to make the article more concise, it was to make the audience more outraged and more likely to share that article with others -- thereby increase the number of page views.

Not that I would expect the author to admit that. The author can't speak to the intent of his editor, obviously. And even if he could, I don't think his editor would be too pleased with him if he did that.

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by simplify on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @07:03PM (#22371515)
Got cut? Meaning you knew about this crucial detail and consciously decided to not include it?
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by brenden2 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:56PM (#22368065)
Thanks for publishing it! It takes a lot of courage to go against the "who's hot in the valley" zeitgeist.

Also, CoderPad was life changing when we started using it at Airbnb. It made phone interviews so much more effective, thanks for creating it.

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by akanet on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @01:39PM (#22368567)
Not having VCs of my own helped a lot!
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by giansegato on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @03:39PM (#22369799)
Why is that? Can you elaborate?
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by AquinasCoder on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:25PM (#22367691)
You mention that there's value in Lambda's mission, but I'm curious as to whether you believe that Lambda's business model is redeemable.

It's hard to argue that there's clearly a major risk involved in attending a program like this, but at the same time it seems to be working for some individuals. Would these high-achieving individuals be able to teach themselves? Possibly. But I'm not sure that going back to the traditional college route is the right choice either. And how can we better help those who lack the aptitude or enjoyment of programming and find out too late into these programs?

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by akanet on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:28PM (#22367718)
Bootcamps probably need a longer and more rigorous trial period - one thing that students were really pissed about was that they didn't find out that Lambda was bad until after the month-long forgiveness period ended.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by mattmcknight on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @01:11PM (#22368236)
Why did you choose to write about this program as opposed to other programs that teach people coding skills, but have vastly worse payment plans, including some which can't even be dispensed in bankruptcy? The criticism seems unmoored from its placement in the set of alternatives for people who want to try to see if they can get a job coding. The undergraduate degree is notoriously bad for this purpose, from time, practicality and cost perspectives. How do you propose that people learn these skills- or learn if they are capable of achieving these skills?
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by akanet on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @01:59PM (#22368789)
Why? Its prominence.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by mattmcknight on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @05:00PM (#22370553)
Do you admit it has advantages over the alternatives? It sure doesn't sound like that in the article, where all you do is bash the company, without mentioning how it is an improvement.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by 737min on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @03:01PM (#22369443)
Exactly ^, Lambda has gotten a lot of mindshare quickly, based on some provable misrepresentations. That’s not good for either bootcamps or startup ecosystem generally.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by mattmcknight on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @07:24PM (#22371650)
"How do you propose that people learn these skills- or learn if they are capable of achieving these skills?"

Is that too difficult to answer for you?

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by lazyasciiart on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:50PM (#22372090)
There might not be a good answer, but that doesn't make the existing attempts good. That argument is the same logic I could use to say "Why did you criticize their plan of hitting people in the head as treatment for stage IV cancer if you haven't got a better proposal?"
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by tomhoward on Thursday February 20, 2020 @09:01AM (#22375084)
Can you explain in what sense people voluntarily signing up for an educational course that they only have to pay for if they make a solid living within 5 years is the equivalent of hitting terminal cancer patients in the head?
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by lazyasciiart on Thursday February 20, 2020 @12:58PM (#22377000)
Well, I can try. So, are you familiar with the general construction "A is to B what C is to D"? If you're American, you might have seen these analogy questions on the SAT.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by tomhoward on Thursday February 20, 2020 @07:11PM (#22379852)
Yes, I understand what that kind of comparison is, but you haven’t substantiated it.

It’s a pretty horrible analogy - demeaning to cancer patients aside from anything else, and seems to seek to tarnish a seemingly well-intentioned business by linking it to something awful, without any basis.

I don’t suggest the company is beyond criticism or without a need to improve; it’s still a fairly new company after all.

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by lazyasciiart on Thursday February 20, 2020 @09:11PM (#22380414)
Demeaning to cancer patients? Huh. I thought I was writing out a really incredibly obviously clear instance of "if a thing is bad, you cannot criticize it unless you provide an alternative - if you cannot provide a better option, then the thing must not be bad". I didn't realize I needed to scaffold this so much for people to actually focus on the logic being criticized and not get hung up on "but this thing isn't bad!?@!??!" How would you have presented it? Or, do you think it's not actually possible in this context to explain why that construction is illogical without upsetting people who like the school?
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by tomhoward on Thursday February 20, 2020 @10:57PM (#22380850)
Anyone who is committed to serious enquiry and good-faith discussion understands that there is a very large class of things that might seem bad at first glance, but turn out not to be so bad, or indeed quite good, when compared against the available alternatives.

This class of things includes pretty much anything that's really important in the world - including economic systems, government policies, human behaviours, and, yes, companies, including ones that offer deferred payment for education that can lead to higher incomes and better standards of living for the customer.

You're clearly intelligent enough to know this but are poisoning the debate by making a comparison with something that is horrible but not at all comparable.

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by lazyasciiart on Thursday February 20, 2020 @11:35PM (#22380969)
What the hell. Obviously I know that many things are maybe not bad. That's why I picked an example where people would not argue about whether it was bad in order to demonstrate the logical point.

It is clear that I not only didn't get my point across but that people don't even believe that the point existed, and I miscommunicated so badly that you're not even willing to believe that I was ever arguing in good faith. Fuck this.

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by mattmcknight on Thursday February 20, 2020 @11:30AM (#22376213)
It's more like, these guys are offering a plan where you get treatment for stage IV cancer and you only have to pay if it works. The other options require you or someone else to pay huge amounts up front, regardless of outcome, and are no better at getting results.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by lazyasciiart on Thursday February 20, 2020 @12:59PM (#22377011)
I wasn't commenting on whether it works. I was showing that his objection to criticism that didn't include a suggested better alternative was illogical.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by mattmcknight on Friday February 21, 2020 @01:27PM (#22385438)
It wasn't just criticism without an alternative. It was saying, this thing is bad, don't use it. If the other things are worse, you still have to use it. This is why your analogy was ineffective, because you used a thing that was obvious worse than the other approaches.

People need to learn things. If funding education through an ISV is the best way to do that, then they should do that, even if there are problems with it. What the article really seemed to be implying was that they shouldn't do it that way, that there was something wrong with it, which justified an extremely negative view of the company, and leaves people with no option to learn to code without large upfront costs or loans to pay back if they are unsuccessful.

Describing the very best option in purely negative terms is misleading.

If you are telling people to stop doing a thing with a x% chance of working, but the other options have a lower chance of working, you are effectively saying don't do the thing at all.

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by lazyasciiart on Friday February 21, 2020 @03:21PM (#22386343)
You are assuming here that you and the speaker have a shared belief that this way to accomplish the thing has a chance of working and is worth doing in the absence of alternatives (or that it is obviously better than alternatives). That is almost certainly a false assumption when someone tells you "don't do that thing". Instead of continuing to hold those assumptions, you should either ignore their opinion altogether or attempt to find out which of those beliefs you don't share.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by kick on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:35PM (#22367799)
These documents show that, as recently as August 2018, a hedge fund paid $10K to purchase half of Lambda School’s ISAs.

Was this at $10k/ISA? And was it half of all ISAs or all of half of the ISAs?

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by akanet on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:36PM (#22367812)
i see now that i could have worded that better - but 10k per entire ISA, and half of ISAs minted
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by snisarenko on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @01:58PM (#22368784)
Hey man. Thank you for publishing this article, and doing actual journalism (researching the actual data, and giving people opportunity to respond). I've been recommending lambda school to my friends, only based on their marketing. I may stop doing that now.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by lonnyk on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:11PM (#22367552)
I have to be honest that I’m not really seeing any major issues here. They _used_ to do something and now they don’t, so he didn’t lie about it. They _have_ had low placement rates and informed their investors, but it’s unclear what the average or common placement rate is and if it’s significantly different from what they claim. And _some_ students didn’t like the curriculum. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

You also make reference to some internal documents. Perhaps sharing them will help further the story?

Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by akanet on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:14PM (#22367576)
I disagree that this is an accurate assessment of my claims. When you claim that you "never have" done something after you've already done it, you're making a statement about both the present and the past. Your point about averages or something is also difficult for me to parse.
Re:Lambda School’s Misleading Promises by AlchemistCamp on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:21PM (#22372200)
Hey Vincent! Great to see you here. Are you gonna go back on IH for office hours this year?

Also how much time did you spend on all of the research for this piece?